Note: Had to vote myself to clear up ties. Don't judge me. I still count. I'm not a corporation of hundreds of people. I'm one guy. I have an opinion.
Slender Man: 3 votes Onryō: 1 vote
Slender Man advances
The Rake: 1 vote Bogeyman: 2 votes
BEN: 2 votes The Tails Doll: 0 votes
Chupacabra/The Goat Sucker: 1 vote Windigo: 3 votes
Goatman: 0 votes Minotaur: 4 votes
Vampire: 4 votes Werewolf: 2 votes
Grim Reaper: 3 votes Four Horsemen: 1 vote
Grim Reaper advances
Bloody Mary: 3 votes Woman in White: 1 vote
Bloody Mary advances
Cockatrice: 2 votes Basilisk: 1 vote
Hydra: 3 votes Cerberus: 1 vote
Banshee: 0 votes Demon: 4 votes
Siren: 1 vote Zombies: 3 votes
Black Dog: 3 votes Bigfoot: 1 vote
Black Dog advances
Jeff the Killer: 1 vote Changeling: 2 votes
Kraken: 1 vote Leviathan: 3 votes
SCP-087: 1 vote SCP-173: 0 votes
Get ready for Round 2!
When I say I'm back...I should really...y'know...stay...