I use a 10-point scale like for MAL...
How do I arrive at my scoring, well generally if I loved the anime it would naturally get a high score. Determining which score I'd give out depends on the characters, the story and animation...sometimes I like the music but it doesn't always help...like the songs from Macross F were pretty good but I hated both female leads singing
I do give 10's...but rarely...to anime that change my view on life....whether its action, fantasy or plain old slice of life....then again Gintama is in a class of its own.
7 is the average....worth watching, entertaining but not just AWE-inspiring
8 is getting there....with just a little more class than the 7's
9's pretty much there....very enjoyable and simply amazing. But like I said they don't add anything to my life like the 10's do.
5- 6 are okay...they aren't exactly a waste of time but they aren't worth much either.
The lowest I've given is a 4....for some reason I possess skills that allow me steer clear of any anime that would make me throw up....and thats what I would give a 1...should I ever find myself unlucky
I rate anime as only good or bad. If it entertains me it is good and if not then it is bad. That isn't to say that everything I think is good I enjoy on an equal level. I can definitely make a top 10 list, but I can't exactly put a rating on any one area because it all comes down to my personal taste, not whether the plot or music, or anything else makes or breaks it.
I enjoy comedy and mystery really well, for example, so that would put shows like Gintama and Detective Conan near or at the top of my list. Could there be anime with a much better rating for plot points, music, animation. Yeah, but it's not my rating, that rating doesn't mean a thing, and that rating will not make me watch the anime nor make it show up in my list because it says it should be there..
I don't really like rating things based on any specific criteria, as I like different things for different reasons. Nonetheless, there is a sort of hierarchy in my head for things I like and don't like, and I've also noticed some trends with the things I like. It seems like most of my favorite series have well-developed characters and interesting dialogue. That is, can I understand the characters, their thoughts, ideas, and motivations? Do they talk about cool ideas, or express their ideas poetically? If the answer to any of those questions is yes, then there is a good chance I will like the series. So if I had to choose any criteria, it would probably be that. I've also noticed that great music has a lot to do with how much I enjoy a series. A good plot comes next. It might seem weird that music is more important than plot, but a good music score can make a huge difference in atmosphere. If there was any sort of ranking, it would probably be this:
3. Above average
6. Completely dropped from disinterest
Edit: So I guess it's a 6-point scale?
i don't use score but rather go by the : to be recommended or not recommended and to whom I'd recommend and who's asking for recommendation
on an personal note i go buy what genera the show is
the art style and level of story
and how attached you get to the story and characters
ignore fan service or laugh at it or bear with it to an point
not an fan of battle royal animes where all the characters die but some i watch to the end
yaoi is an fun pun but if its the back bone of the anime i end up droping
A Ten point rating system, and depending on the anime one matters more than the other,
Five points on characters,
Three Points on story, (Unless its Shoujo)
A Half on music (But the music often affects the mood, soo it depends on the genre)
One and a half on animation (Unless its something like Project K or anything SHAFT,)
Then again, it differs depending on the genre, on Code Geass Characters were more important, in Zetsubou Sensei it was Animation, on Pandora Hearts the music got me over the first episode and on Ouran HSHC or Kuroshitsuji, characters are most important.
I rate by the overall theme of the story, the message(s) it's trying to give the viewer and go from there.
[No information available]
I dont scale them, I just like them or dislike them. If I like them I will be more likely to watch a shows entire run, and maybe even buy it when it gets released. If I dislike it then I just drop it. I may go back and watch it later to see if my views on it change.
+ I plan on finishing
(n) I will watch it when there is nothing to watch
- I gave it a few chances but still not appealing
-- doesnt seem remotely interesting
I usually base my rating on how interesting an anime is in the first few episodes.
Please don't read this sentence. Please ignore first sentence.
Well, I don't really rate, but as I was organizing all the anime I'd seen, I started assigning them either an A, C, or F. I tried to put in as few ratings as possible to get the job done, because I think many rating schemes conceal more information than they tell (for example, in game reviews a 7/10 would be the expected score for a disappointing high-budget release or a good, but unpolished small game - two completely different things). Then I added in A-C and C-F (also known as 'B' and 'D') - which I invented basically so I could give the various Yu-Gi-Oh! franchises an A even though they don't deserve it.
If I were to give numbers to each of those grades, A would be a 90-100, A-C would be a 90-80, C would be a 90-70, C-F would be an 80-60, and F would be 70-0. Wow, I'm harsh.
EDIT: And then most harsh would be a null rating. That would mean I thought it was too bad to keep watching. This is probably my most common score.
i use my own four section scale, including:
i'm semi-active. check my page every week or so.
I'm sort of in the groove of the 10 point system used in MAL.
The most important aspects I pay attention to are the story and characters. Both can really make or break a series for me, for example, I hated the lead for the world god only knows, but the story was too interesting for me to drop. Before I got into the novels, if yo asked me, I could never really tell you what the hell is going on with the plot in index, but I keep comming back everyweek for the characters such as Touma, BiriBiri, Accelerator and Index (and eventually H******) Then I take the art into consideration, ironicly enough for a guy who wants to be a cartoonist, unless its insanley bad I don't really concern myself with it. I mostly take point to bring it to peoples attention when its really good or really bad. To a lesser extent its similar with music. Then I take into consideration my own personal enjoyment of the series and give it an overall rating:
10: Absolutly perfect, everyone could watch it and love it (almost never give out this rating)
9: FANTASTIC! a soild series sure to entertain the masses
8: I'm having too much fun to really give a shit about the flaws
7: Its pretty good, but there some flaws here and there
6: Its alright, but there are alot of irksome flaws
5: I just barely got to finish the damn thing...the flaws
4: I can't do it, I tried but I can not go on.
3: Didn't even get past episode 5
2: Didn't even get past episode 1
1: FUCK YOU (and yes, this is in refrence to the spill crew)
I don't think I've ever given anything a one before or even a 3, even the anime I hate the most only has a 4, so I don't really take myself as hard to please.
Randomness is unavoidable
I use a rating system of 1-5 although it is a 20 point scale (increments of 0.25 i.e 4.00, 4.25, 4.50.....).
07 Ghost 3.00
Baka and Test 5.00
Bamboo Blade 4.75
Clannad: After Story 5.00
Darker than Black 5.00
Fullmetal Alchemist 5.00
Heaven's Lost Property 5.00
Is this a Zombie? 5.00
Kenichi the Mightiest Disciple 5.00
Naruto Movie 1 5.00
Naruto Shippuden 5.00
Ouran High School 5.00
School Rumble 5.00
Spice and Wolf 5.00
Summer Wars 5.00
The Future Diary 5.00
The World God Only Knows 5.00
Guilty Crown 5.00
Mysterious Girlfriend X 5.00
Angel Beats 4.75
Aria the Scarlett Ammo 4.75
Black Cat 4.75
Blue Exorcist 4.75
Chaos Head 4.75
Desert Punk 4.75
Ga Rei Zero 4.75
Heroic Age 4.75
Hikaru No Go 4.75
Last Exile 4.75
Mushi Shi 4.75
Rin-Daughters of Mnemosyne 4.75
Strike Withches 4.75
The Familiar of Zero 4.75
The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya 4.75
Seitokai No Ichizon 4.75
A Certain Magical Index 4.50
Aesthitica of a rogue Hero 4.50
Black Blood Brothers 4.50
Black Butler 4.50
Cardfight Vanguard 4.50
Chrono Crusade 4.50
Demon King Daimao 4.50
D-Gray Man 4.50
Dragonaut- The Resonance 4.50
Fruits Basket 4.50
Full Metal Panic 4.50
Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood 4.50
Kaze No Stigma 4.50
Kiddy Grade 4.50
Moon Phase 4.50
My Bride is a Mermaid 4.50
Naruto Shippuden Movie 3 4.50
Naruto Shippuden Movie 5 4.50
Naruto Spinoff: Rock Lee 4.50
Negima? Magistar Negi Magi 4.50
Samuria Champaloo 4.50
Sands of Destruction 4.50
Sengoku Basara 4.50
So I Can't Play H! 4.50
Soul Eater 4.50
Sword Art Online 4.50
The Ambition of Oda Nobuna 4.50
The Sacred Blacksmith 4.50
Tokyo Majin 4.50
XXXholic: Movie 4.50
Deadman Wonderland 4.50
A Certain Scientific Railgun 4.50
Bleach Movie 2 4.25
Dance in the Vampire Bund 4.25
Eden of the East 4.25
Fairy Tail 4.25
Hayate no Gotoku 4.25
High School DxD 4.25
Naruto Shippuden Movie 2 4.25
Shakugan no Shana 4.25
Tales of Vesperia 4.25
Vampire Knight 4.25
Nakaimo My Little Sister is among them 4.25
11 Eyes 4.00
Blood + 4.00
Chrome Shelled Regios 4.00
Clannad: Movie 4.00
Death Note 4.00
High School of the Dead 4.00
Nabari No Ou 4.00
Oh! Edo Rocket 4.00
Phi Brain 4.00
Princess Jellyfish 4.00
Rosario + Vampire 4.00
The Law of Ueki 4.00
Trinity Blood 4.00
Ah My Goddess 3.75
Asura Cryin 3.75
Black Butler II 3.75
Bleach Movie 1 3.75
Bleach Movie 3 3.75
Bleach Movie 4 3.75
Kyo Kara Maou 3.75
Linebarrells of Iron 3.75
Naruto Shippuden Movie 1 3.75
Naruto Shippuden Movie 4 3.75
Pani Poni Dash! 3.75
Tower of Druaga 3.75
B Gata H Kei 3.50
Excel Saga 3.50
Ino x Boku Secret Service 3.50
Naruto Movie 3 3.25
One Piece 3.25
Naruto Movie 2 3.00
Shattered Angels 2.50
Ikki Tousen 1.50
Steins; Gate 4.50
My Little Monster 4.75
I use the 5 Star system because it's also adaptable to a 1-10 styled ratings used by other places by using half stars if the things I judge by are partially present. I rate by the following criteria:
1. The Storyline: Whether it's entertaining or not or well written
2. Characters: Whether they were interesting, possessed depth, played off of each other, and were developed
3. Emotional Impact: Whether or not I got "into it", like it made me care about the characters, laugh, cry, rage, etc.
4. The Ending: Whether or not it ended well if at all
5. Technical Aspects: Was the animation and music good?
Peace Sells....but Who's buying?
How I rate anime:
I write a general review of it first, and then I give it a letter grade for 3 things: Story, Art, and Characters.
I'll generally give a better review for an anime if it makes me feel emotional. Because you can have a great anime, but without emotion it seems kind of hollow and doesn't leave that much of an impression.
I want my CR membership back :'C