Better Heroine: Nagisa or Menma?

In your opinion, who delivered the heroine role better?
Who do you like better, personality-wise?

Nagisa Furukawa or Meiko Honma?

Nagisa Furukawa

☼ Born with a weak body
☼ Had to repeat senior year twice
☼ Left with no friends until she met Tomoya
☼ Changed Tomoya Okazaki's life forever
☼ Touched the people around her
☼ Major spoiler alert:

Spoiler Alert! Click to show or hide

Important scenes:

[Contains major spoilers)
Hug in the Spring
Tomoya's Confession (Contains major spoilers)

♥____________________♥____________________♥____________________♥____________________♥

Meiko Honma

☼ Died at a young age; becomes a ghost
☼ Reunited her friends who were once split apart by fate
☼ Helped her friends overcome their problems
☼ Changed Jinta's life forever

Important scenes:

Goodbye Menma (Contains major spoilers)
Menma's Wish (AMV)

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Discuss.

chrome_mist 47434 cr points Send Message: 20 / F / Under your skin. Offline	Permalink Reply Quote Posted 1/7/13, edited 1/8/13 In your opinion, who delivered the heroine role better? Who do you like better, personality-wise? Nagisa Furukawa or Meiko Honma? Nagisa Furukawa ☼ Born with a weak body ☼ Had to repeat senior year twice ☼ Left with no friends until she met Tomoya ☼ Changed Tomoya Okazaki's life forever ☼ Touched the people around her ☼ Major spoiler alert: Spoiler Alert! Click to show or hide Dies after giving birth to Usio Important scenes: [Contains major spoilers) Hug in the Spring Tomoya's Confession (Contains major spoilers) ♥____________________♥____________________♥____________________♥____________________♥ Meiko Honma ☼ Died at a young age; becomes a ghost ☼ Reunited her friends who were once split apart by fate ☼ Helped her friends overcome their problems ☼ Changed Jinta's life forever Important scenes: Goodbye Menma (Contains major spoilers) Menma's Wish (AMV) ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Discuss.
	Report to Moderator Will you still love me when I'm no longer young and beautiful?
AnimeKami 50630 cr points Send Message: 22 / M / This Dying World Offline	Permalink Reply Quote Posted 1/7/13 i'll go with the one that actually died
	Report to Moderator I am Optimus Maximus Decimus Meridius Colossus Nemesis Nexus Genesis
	Permalink Reply Quote Posted 1/7/13 Being the cold, ruthless asshole I am, I'll go with the dark and edgy answer of: I didn't give a fuck for either.
	Report to Moderator In loving memory of Cryska.
kufirst 68798 cr points Send Message: 26 / M / USA Offline	Permalink Reply Quote Posted 1/7/13 Menma
	Report to Moderator
stark700 74669 cr points Send Message: 23 / M / Anime World Offline	Permalink Reply Quote Posted 1/7/13 kufirst wrote: Menma
	Report to Moderator Animanga hunter extraordinaire
TotalPotato 18404 cr points Send Message: 23 / M / Scotland Offline	Permalink Reply Quote Posted 1/8/13 What's the point in putting a spoiler tag for one of Nagisa's points when you spoil the exact same thing under "Important Scenes"?
	Report to Moderator
Remove this advertisement
chrome_mist 47434 cr points Send Message: 20 / F / Under your skin. Offline	Permalink Reply Quote Posted 1/8/13 TotalPotato wrote: What's the point in putting a spoiler tag for one of Nagisa's points when you spoil the exact same thing under "Important Scenes"? Oop. Edited it.
	Report to Moderator Will you still love me when I'm no longer young and beautiful?
Customer Support starry 18249 cr points Send Message: 21 / F / Canadaland (Asia... Offline	Permalink Reply Quote Posted 1/8/13 kufirst wrote: Menma
	Report to Moderator I never want to arrive. I love the ride.
xCrimsonEX 626 cr points Send Message: 27 / M / The Abyss of Time Offline	Permalink Reply Quote Posted 1/8/13, edited 1/8/13 Both are equally tragic, for me, and I like both of their personalities in their own stories.
	Report to Moderator As a phantom I drift here and there always seen remembered by few
deadpanditto 33059 cr points Send Message: 45 / M / KC Online	Permalink Reply Quote Posted 1/8/13 Menma
	Report to Moderator
jwaad 5 cr points Send Message: 33 / M Offline	Permalink Reply Quote Posted 1/8/13 Go clannad Negisa
	Report to Moderator
Remove this advertisement
Braxerman 4012 cr points Send Message: 26 / M / Kansas Offline	Permalink Reply Quote Posted 1/8/13 I gotta go with Nagisa. That series touched my life!
	Report to Moderator
Shrapnel893 27393 cr points Send Message: 17 / F / Venice Online	Permalink Reply Quote Posted 1/8/13, edited 1/8/13 Them? Heroines? Pfft. I'm going with Nagisa because she has sex and sex makes babies.
	Report to Moderator [No information available]
ShinnAsukaGSD 4273 cr points Send Message: 24 / M / Bronx New York Offline	Permalink Reply Quote Posted 1/8/13 Nagisa forever clannad change my life.
	Report to Moderator Come Forth Saber
kaamaru 20774 cr points Send Message: 19 / M / UK Online	Permalink Reply Quote Posted 1/8/13 Nagisa by far.
	Report to Moderator

Popular Shows

Platforms and Devices

Premium Memberships

Language

Support

Crunchyroll