Better Heroine: Nagisa or Menma?

AsuraCryin wrote:

Being the cold, ruthless asshole I am, I'll go with the dark and edgy answer of: I didn't give a fuck for either.

dang.....

ShinnAsukaGSD wrote:

Nagisa forever clannad change my life.

^this. Although I really did think Anohana's equally awesome in it's own way. It's just Clannad is pretty dang special.

yugioh5552 4143 cr points Send Message: Offline	Permalink Reply Quote Posted 1/8/13 Nagisa
	Report to Moderator
taonas 16108 cr points Send Message: M Offline	Permalink Reply Quote Posted 1/8/13 Nagisa without question. I found Menma's story to be forced and highly predictable.
	Report to Moderator
reaper429 10277 cr points Send Message: 22 / M / Oshkosh, WI Offline	Permalink Reply Quote Posted 1/13/13 It's a tough choice but i'd have to go with Menma, her story just appealed to my emotions much more.
	Report to Moderator
DarkAnimeFreak 2593 cr points Send Message: 99 / FACEBOOK STALKING Offline	Permalink Reply Quote Posted 1/13/13 Nagisa made me cry my eyes out.
	Report to Moderator ◕‿◕You are so ugly, but your face is so pretty.◕‿◕
darkfire9o9 16288 cr points Send Message: M / Where you are. Online	Permalink Reply Quote Posted 1/13/13 deadpanditto wrote: Menma :) Yeah lol
	Report to Moderator (:
chili17 4413 cr points Send Message: Offline	Permalink Reply Quote Posted 1/13/13 I don't really like Nagisa that much.... and Menma? I KNEW I recognized her from Anohana flower we saw that day Anime....didn't finish it so I can't decide
	Report to Moderator I'm just saying~
Remove this advertisement
kaptainkooleio 4541 cr points Send Message: 21 / M / Sembach-Kaserne,... Offline	Permalink Reply Quote Posted 1/13/13 Nagisa, my reason? Spoiler Alert! Click to show or hide She died giving birth to a child who will die a few years later. though they are magically brought back to life which still confuses me. Clannads still a good anime
	Report to Moderator 296 Animes Under my Belt and counting
chase6565 7728 cr points Send Message: 20 / M / Tuna Salad Offline	Permalink Reply Quote Posted 1/13/13 AsuraCryin wrote: Being the cold, ruthless asshole I am, I'll go with the dark and edgy answer of: I didn't give a fuck for either. dang..... ShinnAsukaGSD wrote: Nagisa forever clannad change my life. ^this. Although I really did think Anohana's equally awesome in it's own way. It's just Clannad is pretty dang special.
	Report to Moderator I LOVE Apple sauce.
ThePinkRanger 27237 cr points Send Message: ℳoяяoωїη∂ Offline	Permalink Reply Quote Posted 1/14/13, edited 1/14/13 taonas wrote: Nagisa without question. I found Menma's story to be forced and highly predictable. Finally someone who feels the same as me about Menma/Anohana. Nagisa for me as well.
	Report to Moderator
mike3391 10106 cr points Send Message: 22 / M / BAYSIDE,NY Offline	Permalink Reply Quote Posted 1/14/13 without a second though i'll go with NAGISA...
	Report to Moderator allright im startiing the new year the way i want....
SvettOter 3128 cr points Send Message: 15 / M / Bergen, Norway Offline	Permalink Reply Quote Posted 1/14/13 NAGISAAAAAA
	Report to Moderator Stupidity is fine! If I can't win with ability, I'll excel through stupidity!
Remove this advertisement
Daeus 8190 cr points Send Message: M Online	Permalink Reply Quote Posted 1/14/13 I hate clannad, so, Menma
	Report to Moderator "The present it's nothing more than a fleeting particle from the past"
Quarlo 6609 cr points Send Message: M / San Antonio Offline	Permalink Reply Quote Posted 1/14/13 Nagisa Furukawa. I can't hear the season 2 openning credits song without getting choked up. I named my cat after her.
	Report to Moderator
YuSooKey 5248 cr points Send Message: 25 / M / Virginia, USA Offline	Permalink Reply Quote Posted 1/14/13 Menma really moved the story along in AnoHana while Nagisa was just placed there and things happened around her. Even though I like Clannad more, Menma is a better heroine.
	Report to Moderator - illicit entry
KwongColin 232 cr points Send Message: 21 / M Offline	Permalink Reply Quote Posted 1/20/13 Nagisa
	Report to Moderator

Popular Shows

Platforms and Devices

Premium Memberships

Language

Support

Crunchyroll