Remove this ad
» Music
» DBSK
(3,828 posts)
» Super Junior
(1,817 posts)
» Fahrenheit
(1,509 posts)
» NewS
(1,125 posts)
» Hey Say JUMP
(1,086 posts)
» Chris Lee
(1,062 posts)
» Big Bang
(922 posts)
» Arashi
(858 posts)
First  Previous  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  Next  Last
Post Reply Image Favorite Why can't Asian artists make it big in America?
6636 cr points
Send Message: Quick Send PM Quick GB Post
19 / M / In my mind fighti...
Image Offline
Posted Feb 7 2008, edited Apr 21 2008

kiroxy93 wrote:

I know right?
As far as i know, there are Asian actors and actresses, but not Artists.

Min debut in America, she's from korea, under Lil' John, but she's not that
popular yet. She's a great dancer though!


man min is the shit i heard a song a whil back with her in it and i went crazy she'll make it big
5956 cr points
Send Message: Quick Send PM Quick GB Post
16 / F / USA
Image Offline
Posted Feb 7 2008, edited Apr 21 2008
'Cause they sing in Japanese?

I guess its pretty much the same reason American artists can't make it big there: Language differences.
78 cr points
Send Message: Quick Send PM Quick GB Post
17 / F / [[818]] California
Image Offline
Posted Feb 7 2008, edited Apr 21 2008
well in america there are some artist that brings spanish in their songs and americans still listen to it,
like Shakira, I wonder why too o.o asians can sing english and put some of our language in it or something.
i would support that if somebody does make it.
4686 cr points
Send Message: Quick Send PM Quick GB Post
15 / F / Canada
Image Offline
Posted Feb 7 2008, edited Apr 21 2008
because maybe they can't really speak english... Image
i thought so
Posted Feb 7 2008, edited Apr 21 2008

um2456 wrote:

maybe cus of there poor english skills



not ALLLASIANShave poor english skills..
it just depends on who it is,or wut dey r tryin to say.

Image
7483 cr points
Send Message: Quick Send PM Quick GB Post
69 / M / Florida, US
Image Offline
Posted Feb 7 2008, edited Apr 21 2008
Most are trained since as young as 10-14. But they still have accents. Asian music and fashion is still very different from mainstream America. Another thing is that the biggest Asian artists are people that are trained and produced by the Korean industry. So, they don't have their own songs and don't really get the credit as artists. Merely performers. Logically, if you didn't make it and are just performing it; you're not an artist, you're a performer. Asia is trying to break into the US with pop idol looks, fashion, etc. That's basically the formula for a boy band or teen idol. It won't be easy to break into the US (especially as a guy) as a boy band type of performer even if you claim that you aren't. Not only are boy bands a 90s thing, Caucasian image is too popular in America to lose out to Asian looks. Asia also doesn't have the same diversity as the US, I think. The US seems to have so much influence on the world because it has a huge pool of different cultures, personalities, styles, and talent. You want to find a Korean? You want to see a Cuban? etc etc.. You can find them all in the US. O yea. Americans find Asian music too pop/girly.
7483 cr points
Send Message: Quick Send PM Quick GB Post
69 / M / Florida, US
Image Offline
Posted Feb 7 2008, edited Apr 21 2008
Check this singer out.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x961Goes_UQ

There are some good singers out there in Asia. I think the music industry in Asia worries about image and dancing too much. They just want them to have good singing skills then train them on singing. Rather than finding the ones who have incredible voices.
951 cr points
Send Message: Quick Send PM Quick GB Post
15 / F / ...
Image Offline
Posted Feb 7 2008, edited Apr 21 2008
ummm... i agree with many of you...but i from how i see it...asian music and american music are TOTALLY different unlesss you take big bang- which they are like americanized which overall is yg family.....and sm town is like wayy girlyish for americans and jyp is just korean...so yeah that difference is pretty big and makes a difference....oh and im korean and dont really listen to other asian music so sorry if im being self centered on only korean music
52 cr points
Send Message: Quick Send PM Quick GB Post
Image Offline
Posted Feb 7 2008, edited Apr 21 2008
It's naive to think America isn't a racist country. Don't kid yourself.
432 cr points
Send Message: Quick Send PM Quick GB Post
23 / F / Melb, AUS
Image Offline
Posted Feb 7 2008, edited Apr 21 2008

DreamerD wrote:

It's naive to think America isn't a racist country. Don't kid yourself.


lol! well said...
17 cr points
Send Message: Quick Send PM Quick GB Post
20 / M
Image Offline
Posted Feb 7 2008, edited Apr 21 2008

Ghostie wrote:


rorakitsuzu wrote:

I think they're racists, that's why Asian artists don't make it big there. I'm a Filipino, and I know a lot of bands and artists in the Philippines, and I think that they're really good. I also think that they're better than some of the American artists.

But Jasmine Trias is a different situation, she just joined the American Idol and luckily, she was on 3rd place. But she's still not that popular with the Americans.

I also listen to Korean and Japanese music too, and they're not bad either. Eventhough I can't understand it.

I think that only a few Asian artists will only make it big in America. Hell, they think they're superior. So there's nothing we can do about it. It's good though, that the Asians appreciate each other's music.

Hopefully, someday, Asians can make it big in America.



That's the conclusion everyone wants to come to because it's an easy way to sum it up.

It's really not that at all.

Americans really tend to shy away from what's 'different.'

Until some really big breakout star hits the U.S.A, or an A-lister points out the talent of an Asian individual, there won't be any Asians in the music industry.


Americans are racist. most whites and blacks and mexicans are racist toward asians becuase we generally considered less superior. becuase we generally have more money and study harder. but asians are the greatest race on the earth. america is a bad place to live most people here are ignorant and wanna live a thug life. which is stupid
9 cr points
Send Message: Quick Send PM Quick GB Post
Image Offline
Posted Feb 7 2008, edited Apr 21 2008

aznluck7144 wrote:
Americans are racist. most whites and blacks and mexicans are racist toward asians becuase we generally considered less superior. becuase we generally have more money and study harder. but asians are the greatest race on the earth. america is a bad place to live most people here are ignorant and wanna live a thug life. which is stupid


Alright, I can see that you people here at CrunchyRoll aren't going to take my advice and think before you post, so I'm just going to start correcting the stupid people from time to time.

Obviously, I'm starting with aznluck7144 as the quote above is slightly hypocritical. Now, aznluck7144 is calling Americans racist, yet aznluck7144 seems to be referring to the Hispanic "race" as "Mexicans". I'm basing this on the fact that aznluck7144 mentions "whites", "blacks", and "asians" in the same sentence, all of which are considered "races". However, there is more to the "Hispanic race" than just "Mexicans", I'm afraid.

Furthermore, "Asians" are also considered "American" if they are born within the US or one of its territories. So, one could make the case that aznluck7144 is implying that Asian Americans are "racist" against the "Asian race" as well.

Lastly, there are quite a few "Mexicans" and Filipinos that have a little Spanish in them, seeing as they both had contact with the Spaniards a while back. The relationship they had with the Spaniards was about the same as well, so a lot of "Mexicans" and Filipinos have something in common as far as their blood goes, especially with all the time that has passed since those times. It's interesting that most Filipinos seem to embrace their "Asian" side more whereas "Mexicans" seem to foresake their "Native American" side.

At any rate, aznluck7144 is a moron and so are most of the individuals that posted after I did.
4177 cr points
Send Message: Quick Send PM Quick GB Post
17 / M
Image Offline
Posted Feb 7 2008, edited Apr 21 2008

DreamerD wrote:

It's naive to think America isn't a racist country. Don't kid yourself.
america isn't the only place ethier...japan is pretty racist as well
HypnoSurf22's Avatar
Level 0 Boy
1836 cr points
Send Message: Quick Send PM Quick GB Post
69 / M / NJ, USA
Image Offline
Posted Feb 7 2008, edited Apr 21 2008
its because the typical asn pop star is not good enough to compete. even a superstar like utada hikaru is nothing special.
228 cr points
Send Message: Quick Send PM Quick GB Post
M
Image Offline
Posted Feb 7 2008, edited Apr 21 2008

rockangel7589 wrote:

because maybe they can't really speak english... Image
i thought so



ever heard famous singers from asia speak english I have and majority of them sound like FOBS lol except Korean singer Eugene she speaks excellent english, I bet she's the best singer from Asia to have a great career here only if she wants to Image
First  Previous  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  Next  Last
You must be logged in to post!