Q to those who've seen the "Disappearance" Haruhi S. movie...
13466 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
28 / M / under fire
Offline
Posted 5/19/13 , edited 5/19/13
I just finally got around to watching this movie, so don't hate me. This is all spoilers so if you haven't watched it, it's your funderal. I gave fair warning.

Okay...yeah I give up. I've googled the hell out of it searching for a finite answer but I've read maybe close to 3-4 different explanations all from people who say they've read the novels or that they're sure that's how it happened. I can actually surprisingly understand all of the other confusing crud that this movie throws at you, along with the fact it's tied to an equally confusing series with an even more confusing source material. I just have one question, that no seemingly up to two people can agree on in terms of an answer...

Who the hell pushed Kyon down the stairs?

-I've heard that Nagato changed reality and/or altered everyones mind.
-I've heard it was just a different timeline Nagato creating the situation to cover up for the stab wound he'd be entering the "original" time line with.
-I've heard that it was nobody, and Haruhi imagines up culprits when she doesn't want to believe something happened.
-I've even heard it was Mikuru, because seeing as how there's always a form of her present that knows everything that's going to happen, she gives it away by showing so many feelings of despair near the end during the situation Kyon was being told what he had to do. This is presumably because she knows what has to be done but obviously doesn't like it, and is further supported by the fact that Haruhi claims the "phantom girl" was wearing a skirt...and future Asahina does indeed wear one. If she were wearing a school uniform...maybe Haruhi would have just said that instead of simply a "skirt"?

Anyways this is stressing me since usually when I have a question like this I smack it in to google and boom the first couple links take me to threads with people who understood it better than I or read the manga/novels a lot and have a complete idea.

When googling this question I am frustratingly met with "Well duh it was pretty obvious who did it..." in numerous posts by those who seemingly know, or the silly variance of suggested ideas above.

Someone put my mind at ease here...who dun it?
29767 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
28
Offline
Posted 5/19/13 , edited 5/19/13
Sailor Candy Moderator
200584 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
28
Offline
Posted 5/19/13
Next time please ask all anime questions here The anime/manga help thread.
All questions in The general help thread
When making a topic refrain from making personal threads or "I need help" threads. Personal and help threads will automatically get locked. Whether you receive your answer or not.
As personal threads are not allowed this thread is locked. Also, please see the site rules so that none of your future threads will suffer the same fate here: http://www.crunchyroll.com/forumtopic-406095/crunchyroll-site-forum-rules
You must be logged in to post.