Ef: A Tale of Melodies.VS A Tale of Memories

Tashfinz 44857 cr points Send Message: 25 / M / England Offline	Permalink Reply Quote Posted 7/4/13 Just finished both of the series. Never thought I'd find Tales of Melodies better, after enjoying a heck of a lot of Memories. I particularly enjoyed seeing the anime jump from past to present, back and forth I felt more for the characters in tale of melodies than memories, especially for Yuuko. I wonder if they can get another series in since the manga is still ongoing. lock if duplicate Quick question, Which couple do you think had the best story?
	Report to Moderator
AnimeKami 107355 cr points Send Message: 27 / M / This Dying World Offline	Permalink Reply Quote Posted 7/4/13 miya miya and hiro hiro
	Report to Moderator His Holiness Optimus Maximus Decimus Meridius Colossus Nemesis Nexus Genesis
noraa3812 14458 cr points Send Message: 31 / M / Jacksonville, Texas Offline	Permalink Reply Quote Posted 7/4/13 I prefer the Renji and Chihiro story. In regards to memories vs. melodies, I prefer memories, mainly because it has 2 very good stories while melodies has 1 that is very good and 1 that is so-so.
	Report to Moderator
PatrickAupperleUtexas 39482 cr points Send Message: 24 / M / University of Tex... Offline	Permalink Reply Quote Posted 7/4/13 , edited 7/4/13 Tashfinz wrote: Just finished both of the series. Never thought I'd find Tales of Melodies better, after enjoying a heck of a lot of Memories. I particularly enjoyed seeing the anime jump from past to present, back and forth I felt more for the characters in tale of melodies than memories, especially for Yuuko. I wonder if they can get another series in since the manga is still ongoing. lock if duplicate Quick question, Which couple do you think had the best story? I enjoyed Melodies more. While I didn't really care too much for Mizuki's story, Yuuko's was really great. Memories was a lot of fun as well, and I certainly loved them both, but Yuuko's story may be one of the single greatest things I have seen. As soon as MangaGamer gets ahold of Ef: The Latter Tale, I am certainly buying both visual novels. As far as continuing mangas go, I don't think that means much. I am pretty sure that the show (and Manga) are based on the visual novels (NSFW:http://www.mangagamer.com/detail.php?goods_type=1&product_code=22). The Wikipedia article refers to the manga as an adaptation of the visual novels (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ef_a_fairy_tale_of_the_two#Manga). It is written by the scenario writers of the VN, though, so I guess it could contain additional canon material that could possibly be adapted, but I wouldn't count on it.
	Report to Moderator
KillerZEK87 21922 cr points Send Message: 30 / M / Arizona Offline	Permalink Reply Quote Posted 7/4/13 Memories kicks the shit out of melodies IMO. Memories is one of my favorite romantic dramas ever and it's just so beautiful to look at the art animation. Melodies was a letdown that couldn't hold up to what Memories was.
	Report to Moderator https://www.youtube.com/user/everythinganimated87
kaname08 20312 cr points Send Message: http://myanimelis... Offline	Permalink Reply Quote Posted 7/5/13 i equally liked them both XD really nice romance anime
	Report to Moderator occupation: sleepiest girl on the planet
AnimeKami 107355 cr points Send Message: 27 / M / This Dying World Offline	Permalink Reply Quote Posted 7/5/13 kaname08 wrote: i equally liked them both XD really nice romance anime I told you this 2 years ago and you didn't believe me >.>
	Report to Moderator His Holiness Optimus Maximus Decimus Meridius Colossus Nemesis Nexus Genesis
kaname08 20312 cr points Send Message: http://myanimelis... Offline	Permalink Reply Quote Posted 7/5/13 AnimeKami wrote: kaname08 wrote: i equally liked them both XD really nice romance anime I told you this 2 years ago and you didn't believe me >.> lol alright forgive me, i didn't believe you back then XP and it wasn't even 2yrs ago ... it was like '08 or '09 .... your memory ish really failing you :P
	Report to Moderator occupation: sleepiest girl on the planet
observantzani 61729 cr points Send Message: 26 / F Offline	Permalink Reply Quote Posted 7/6/13 Memories definitely. But Melodies is still good. It kinda connects everything together.
	Report to Moderator
Mikey435 17388 cr points Send Message: 22 / M / New Jersey Online	Permalink Reply Quote Posted 7/6/13 Melodies is more serious while Memories has more generic settings. I thought these shows were both extremely engaging, and were equal. I loved how minor characters and major characters switched roles between the series and they received character development throughout both. This series is definitely a gem. To answer the OP: The best relationship was without a doubt: Yuuko and Himura.
	Report to Moderator

Quote Selected

You must be logged in to post.

Popular Shows

Platforms and Devices

Premium Memberships

Language

Support

Crunchyroll Store

Crunchyroll