Why can't Anime writers create good villains?
50983 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
41 / M / Oakland, CA
Offline
Posted 10/13/13
This one is inspired by me finally getting around to watching SAO, specifically the second half.

The bad guy is, well, cartoonishly evil and awful. I'm guessing that's pretty generally accepted.

The thing is, why can't they do good, convincing ones? Whatsisname from Sword Art is the same as Aizen from bleach is the same as most of the serious enemies in Gintama, is the same as the evil genius guy from Birdy the Mighty, is a character I have to have seen a million times before.

So I'll split this into two parts;

First, why does Japan hate geniuses? They're so often embittered and insane for no very clear reason.

Second, why can't they give their badguys any goddamn subtlety or convincing characterization at all?

~~~

These are admittedly pretty rhetorical questions, but it's good to get such things off your chest.
22236 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
35 / M
Offline
Posted 10/13/13
Cartonish villains are just more fun.

But it's not so much that they hate geniuses. I think they just try and do what's more fun.

And secondly, I think it all depends on which anime you watch. The villains in Black Lagoon, Cowboy Bepop weren't cartoonish at all.
One Punch Mod
85810 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
F / Boston-ish
Offline
Posted 10/13/13 , edited 10/13/13


Hi there! This sounds like a good rant, and good questions to share in the existing thread about good and bad villiains here:

/forumtopic-812003/villains

Please do post in that thread, since I'm closing this one.

locked and closed (since this essentially duplicates that existing topic and duplicate topics aren't allowed).
You must be logged in to post.