First  Prev  1  2  Next  Last
Case of re-uploads of animes: Suicider
8059 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / F / floating....away....
Offline
Posted 1/31/08
hes a mod. he dosent need the points.. thats one of the reasons that the mods made the extended disscussion..(ssoo out of topic here) because mods were pissed that new CR members are making forums with no senses and some members just answer with one or two sentences. (this is just an example) besides.. mods have such privileges that points are like nothing to them. they are more on badges i think. i dont know.
46432 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
30 / F / Japan
Offline
Posted 1/31/08
ummmm I think you should let the mod do what he wants. I understand where you are coming from but you should personally go to the mods themselves if it really bothers you that much because only then will something be done about it. I don't think you are going to get anywhere by making a thread about it .
Posted 2/1/08
so? who the hell cares? people re upload all of the tme
142
8794 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
25 / M / Sweden
Offline
Posted 2/1/08
Yes but: if you have searched all day after an anime episode, finds it then uploads it, waits 20 min for it to encode then waiting several hours for the acception only to be denied that another ****er uploaded it and removed yours kinda pisses you of (happened me with a katekyo hitman episode).
17094 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
Offline
Posted 2/1/08
question... how do you know that Suicider is the one approving he's own video?
also you can't really say there is any different seeing as you've never had seem them in high quality trust me... if he wasn't replacing for a good reason, do you think the anime mods would allow it?
70098 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
M / Wa Wa Land
Offline
Posted 2/1/08

taufiq1991 wrote:

well the previous uploaders had a hard time uploading it n suicider simply remove it, wat bullshit is that? oh yea he reupload minami-ke okawari ep 2
if he wan to upload all animes so much n only his way, might as well to tell all members dont upload any animes fckin retard. let him do the job u no life shyt fckin retard


calm down (?) like the others said PM mods. =P mostly him
Ronin
95035 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
30 / M / California
Offline
Posted 2/1/08
soccerscot15 uploaded the following file:
[AEN]_Bamboo_Blade_15_[Xvid][704x400] [7E6DD087].avi

and

Suicider uploaded this file:
[Huzzah-Doremi]_Bamboo_Blade_15_[9564333A].avi

After looking into it, I saw that Huzzah-Doremi is supposed to have better fansubs for this series. So this proves that Suicider just reuploaded for better quality. This shows how pointless this topic is.

Locked
46535 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
Offline
Posted 2/1/08
^ great you beat me and now my post sucks yay!


taufiq1991 wrote:

Suicider is misusing his mod power to reupload animes n delete the previous 1 so that he can get more points
recently the bamboo blade ep 15 was reuploaded by suicider but i know theres no difference between the 2 files; it has the same qualities.
requesting to revoke his mod power pls


you pretty much have nothing to support your argument.

I suggest some screenshots and details next time to prove your case. are you sure the size of the video was identical? both in lo and high quality? (In high quality the standard size changes too, so if a replacement gives a better resolution, we change it.) are you sure the it was the exact same file, same sub group, etc? Now let me break some of your assumptions.

1. guess what? suicider never approves anime videos.
2. we look at reuploads before replacing them.
3. just in case I thought you should know this: the approval list goes is ordered by date, meaning, if there are two videos of the same episode the one at the top gets approved because it was uploaded first.
4. sometimes subbers release a second version of a video because a line is missing or an improvement is made so the video may look exactly the same but it is not.
5. other reasons for replacing are resolution and bigger subs.
6. there is a page that shows every action a mod makes, so if there is abuse of power, we will notice way ahead of any of you
7. when approving a video we can see the name of the original file. example [Huzzah-Doremi]_Bamboo_Blade_15_[9564333A].avi
thus, if a video is identical, when a media mod compares the uploaded one with the replacement it's rare to miss it.
8. we approve a lot of stuff and many of thse videos are not well labeled when uploaded, so the number of videos plus quality of description given by the uploader increase the probability of a mistake. which can be prefectly pointed out in the site & feedback section of this forum instead of making a weak argument thread about a hypothetical abuse of power


~never assume the obvious is true
First  Prev  1  2  Next  Last
You must be logged in to post.