First  Prev  1  2  Next  Last
ANN Best of 2014
55581 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
M
Offline
Posted 12/18/14

Koda89 wrote:


h9902014 wrote:


Koda89 wrote:


h9902014 wrote:

Gosh...man those people liked Space Dandy wayyy too much.


Well it is ANN. It has been well established that they have shit taste in anime.


I'm guessing you top anime of 2014 was different from them as well.


Naturally. First and foremost....I'm not doing my list YET because we still have some 2014 shows not yet finished. Plus unlike them I'm doing the reverse, I am counting shows from 2013 that ended in 2014(like Kill la Kill), and won't be counting shows from 2014 that are still going.

For me, a show has to end at least one season in that given year. So things like Parasyte, Shirobako, and Your Lie in April, which continue into 2015 without having completed a season, won't be eligible for me. However in the case of something like Log Horizon, it's first season will be eligible, but its second won't. Kind of get what I'm saying?

Basically, I can't judge things that haven't completed its season. Unlike ANN, which are more than happy to judge shows before they finish at least one season.


Yea alright I get what you're saying. Yea, it's for the best that rankings aren't made until every show for this season is completed. I agree.

So they rate before the show's finished huh.

So wait since Fate Stay Night is getting 2 split cours, is that also 2015 for you as well?
52863 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
24 / M / CA
Offline
Posted 12/18/14
I see nothing wrong with the ANN list
41312 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
54 / M / East Coast
Online
Posted 12/18/14

sonic720 wrote:


Koda89 wrote:

h9902014 wrote:
Gosh...man those people liked Space Dandy wayyy too much.


Well it is ANN. It has been well established that they have shit taste in anime.


QFE

The fan list is about what I expected at least.


I like Sonic and Koda views they post a lot and does h9902014

. I posted it because odf all the differences in Anime Likes.

Now I took ANN to task last week for a lousy review and took some heat for it Dont worry I have my anime logic barrier up XD

Now people are saying thier picks are lousy So many opions in anime.

It has gotten to a point where only your like and tastes should matter. Because I am totaaly confused from one review to the next > one will thrasg a show/ EP and the fans are no better.

You really got to know your forum posters to take their word.

I wiil continue watch anime on my owm judgement and everybody else should too!

Koda89 
32613 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / M / Oklahoma City, OK
Online
Posted 12/18/14

h9902014 wrote:


Koda89 wrote:


h9902014 wrote:


Koda89 wrote:


h9902014 wrote:

Gosh...man those people liked Space Dandy wayyy too much.


Well it is ANN. It has been well established that they have shit taste in anime.


I'm guessing you top anime of 2014 was different from them as well.


Naturally. First and foremost....I'm not doing my list YET because we still have some 2014 shows not yet finished. Plus unlike them I'm doing the reverse, I am counting shows from 2013 that ended in 2014(like Kill la Kill), and won't be counting shows from 2014 that are still going.

For me, a show has to end at least one season in that given year. So things like Parasyte, Shirobako, and Your Lie in April, which continue into 2015 without having completed a season, won't be eligible for me. However in the case of something like Log Horizon, it's first season will be eligible, but its second won't. Kind of get what I'm saying?

Basically, I can't judge things that haven't completed its season. Unlike ANN, which are more than happy to judge shows before they finish at least one season.


Yea alright I get what you're saying. Yea, it's for the best that rankings aren't made until every show for this season is completed. I agree.

So they rate before the show's finished huh.

So wait since Fate Stay Night is getting 2 split cours, is that also 2015 for you as well?

Ah, nah, Fate/stay night will count as 2014, cause it is finishing its first season this year. Season/cour, whatever, as long as it doesn't air in both the Fall of one year and the Winter of the next year, it is good to go with me.
215009 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / M / Anime World
Offline
Posted 12/18/14 , edited 12/18/14
Ping Pong should be on top 3 on that list. Really wish Jojo, Barakamon, Haikyu, Black Butler: Book of Circus, and Rage of Bahamut: Genesis to rank a bit higher too....
Posted 12/18/14

Koda89 wrote:

Naturally. First and foremost....I'm not doing my list YET because we still have some 2014 shows not yet finished. Plus unlike them I'm doing the reverse, I am counting shows from 2013 that ended in 2014(like Kill la Kill), and won't be counting shows from 2014 that are still going.

For me, a show has to end at least one season in that given year. So things like Parasyte, Shirobako, and Your Lie in April, which continue into 2015 without having completed a season, won't be eligible for me. However in the case of something like Log Horizon, it's first season will be eligible, but its second won't. Kind of get what I'm saying?

Basically, I can't judge things that haven't completed its season. Unlike ANN, which are more than happy to judge shows before they finish at least one season.


I am exactly the same in that regard. I don't put incomplete Anime on my list since they are practically impossible to judge.
That's what I don't get about all the people telling me that Parasyte is the Anime of the year for 2014, that show isn't even half done yet, calm down people, it could be utterly terrible once it is done. A series has a beginning, a middle and an end, how can you comment on the definitive quality of a show and call it your favourite when we have just got into the middle part?

BTW: I dropped Space Dandy after five episodes and haven't come to regret that since. Screw popular oppinions!
Koda89 
32613 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / M / Oklahoma City, OK
Online
Posted 12/18/14

Okocha119 wrote:


Koda89 wrote:

Naturally. First and foremost....I'm not doing my list YET because we still have some 2014 shows not yet finished. Plus unlike them I'm doing the reverse, I am counting shows from 2013 that ended in 2014(like Kill la Kill), and won't be counting shows from 2014 that are still going.

For me, a show has to end at least one season in that given year. So things like Parasyte, Shirobako, and Your Lie in April, which continue into 2015 without having completed a season, won't be eligible for me. However in the case of something like Log Horizon, it's first season will be eligible, but its second won't. Kind of get what I'm saying?

Basically, I can't judge things that haven't completed its season. Unlike ANN, which are more than happy to judge shows before they finish at least one season.


I am exactly the same in that regard. I don't put incomplete Anime on my list since they are practically impossible to judge.
That's what I don't get about all the people telling me that Parasyte is the Anime of the year for 2014, that show isn't even half done yet, calm down people, it could be utterly terrible once it is done. A series has a beginning, a middle and an end, how can you comment on the definitive quality of a show and call it your favourite when we have just got into the middle part?

BTW: I dropped Space Dandy after five episodes and haven't come to regret that since. Screw popular oppinions!


If they stick to the manga, or even remotely close to the manga, then Parasyte will be pretty damn good all things told. But yeah, point taken. It's not even halfway done and a lot of people already want to crown it. You just never know until it is over. Just look at Akame ga Kill! and Terror in Resonance. Both started great, then......yeesh.....
11800 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
27 / M
Offline
Posted 12/18/14 , edited 12/18/14

Koda89 wrote:


Okocha119 wrote:


Koda89 wrote:

Naturally. First and foremost....I'm not doing my list YET because we still have some 2014 shows not yet finished. Plus unlike them I'm doing the reverse, I am counting shows from 2013 that ended in 2014(like Kill la Kill), and won't be counting shows from 2014 that are still going.

For me, a show has to end at least one season in that given year. So things like Parasyte, Shirobako, and Your Lie in April, which continue into 2015 without having completed a season, won't be eligible for me. However in the case of something like Log Horizon, it's first season will be eligible, but its second won't. Kind of get what I'm saying?

Basically, I can't judge things that haven't completed its season. Unlike ANN, which are more than happy to judge shows before they finish at least one season.


I am exactly the same in that regard. I don't put incomplete Anime on my list since they are practically impossible to judge.
That's what I don't get about all the people telling me that Parasyte is the Anime of the year for 2014, that show isn't even half done yet, calm down people, it could be utterly terrible once it is done. A series has a beginning, a middle and an end, how can you comment on the definitive quality of a show and call it your favourite when we have just got into the middle part?

BTW: I dropped Space Dandy after five episodes and haven't come to regret that since. Screw popular oppinions!


If they stick to the manga, or even remotely close to the manga, then Parasyte will be pretty damn good all things told. But yeah, point taken. It's not even halfway done and a lot of people already want to crown it. You just never know until it is over. Just look at Akame ga Kill! and Terror in Resonance. Both started great, then......yeesh.....


To be fair, I want to see the rating of Parasyte and FSN when they are both over, FSN is only like .3% behind it and this is FSN's slow half. There's a certain point in the VN that it picks up in and just doesn't slow down, i'm pretty sure that point will be the cliffhanger this cour. Second Cour is the amazing one, from what your saying Parasyte will also be amazing so I see them competing till the very end.

Sailor Candy Moderator
200584 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
28
Offline
Posted 12/27/15
"Year-end cleanup. Closing threads with no activity since 2014."
First  Prev  1  2  Next  Last
You must be logged in to post.