First  Prev  1  2  3  4  Next  Last
Slaine vs. Inaho
7565 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
19 / M / California
Offline
Posted 1/6/15

MartianMage wrote:


PrincipeCapio wrote:


MartianMage wrote:


PrincipeCapio wrote:

Second, Slaine is a crappy character with kiddish characteristic as well but at the very least he has the most potential, he's the most realistic, we would all act the same as him if things like that happen in real life.


I just had to roll my eyes on that one


Do please tell me what would be your reaction after seeing your loved one, to whom you've been protecting the whole entire time falls for someone else in front of you and further shot at in front of you and moreover, to see the guy that you had help in the beginning who in turn betrayed you and was the cause of the suffering that was inflicted to you -- torture.

Tell me, will you feel hatred? What will you do when the guy points the gun at you? Would you let him shoot you?
Would you feel stable knowing that everything happened all at once in that single event while he was oblivious trying to protect the girl that he loved?


Yes, let's ignore the mountains of extremely stupid decisions Slaine made throughout the series and focus on that 1 part where a lot of people don't even complain about.

also

moreover, to see the guy that you had help in the beginning who in turn betrayed you and was the cause of the suffering that was inflicted to you -- torture.

Do you seriously want to debate episode 7 with me and have me break down the facts to you why it was Slaine's stupidity that he ended up in that situation?



He's not a gary stu like Inaho, he's the embodiment of a teenager. He did what he could to protect the princess through his own choices, he thought he could trust people like the emperor but was betrayed? Is that a stupid decision? No because most people would do this as well. He tried to get help from the samurai guy. Is that a stupid decision? No, because Slaine is all alone in the Martian world and desperation can well fit in.

I'm gonna log for the night, I'll be free to defend my position tomorrow but so far things looking bad, everyone is simply sharing their shallow thinking here especially those who admit they like gary stu characters just because.
81839 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
26 / M
Online
Posted 1/6/15 , edited 1/6/15



^Inaho.^
20283 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
http://myanimelis...
Offline
Posted 1/6/15

AnimeKami wrote:


kaname08 wrote:

I still want Inaho alive in the second season, he better be there with his emotionless character lol


OOO hai!


Lelouch
7565 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
19 / M / California
Offline
Posted 1/6/15 , edited 1/6/15

EJHicks wrote:


PrincipeCapio wrote:

First and foremost, I will say how much I strongly dislike Inaho and his unrealistic cardboard self, and no he's a crappy character, literacy wise.

Second, Slaine is a crappy character with kiddish characteristic as well but at the very least he has the most potential, he's the most realistic, we would all act the same as him if things like that happen in real life.

Third, wake up anime audience. Do not fall for the generic new anime lead with the intelligence but crappy emotions, they've been hoarding the new anime lately it's almost pathetic and now Inaho shows himself killing everyone without flaws?

What's so fun about that? There is no fun when a character singlehandedly kills every enemy, every story must have a resistance especially to the main character that would derail him and thus make him a better character. It's all the same for us real people, we experience experience and change, we experience resistance, we change, we encounter shocking events, our human self derails with unsuspected actions and we live through it; that being change to be a better person wearing a guilty crown or fall to darkness. That is Slaine's potential.

Inoha's potential is just beating everyone else, that's simply it unless he has a backstory.

Wake up please, get to know your basic literacy plots.



Basically this is what I see between Inaho fan & Slaine fan:

Inaho fans: Thinks Naruto should beat Sasuke, Kakashi, Zabuza, Obito and that's simply it and they would falls over heels for "exciting battles" and always say something cool like "This is war" and be a cardboard emotion box.

Slaine Fans: Thinks Naruto should have more resistance like its original plot, he keeps losing but throughout he matures more and more, finds himself but his goal to be with Sakura/Himesama is always there.

I look forward to those who can oppose me and defend CardBoard Inoha.



First, I would NOT rescue the person who told me straight to my face that he was trying to kill the person I've been through hell trying to rescue and protect. I am not that stupid.

Secondly, I see nothing wrong with enjoying someone who uses their intelligence to overcome a disadvantage instead of the just-in-time power-ups or preservering through sheer willpower and determination. Also, the only one I remember him beating single-handedly is the final boss guy. Every other time, he was surrounded by allies who assisted him.

Thirdly, I personally think Inaho is much more emotionally than people give him credit for but that could vary depending on how you interpret the scenes.


How did he react to that characters death in the first episodes? His face didn't even change one bit, he probably thinks "This is war".
And he was the one that executed and planned all the mission/plans so it's all his glory anyways.
They basically cut and paste Lelouch's intellegence and a cardboard and tada Inoha and they probably know that fans like you who have no basic fundementals to the rule of English would like him just because he's all this badass and stuff.

EDIT: Not a lelouch cause lelouch had a lot of failures too so it doesn't count, think of someone perfect and paste it onto a cardboard and tada Inaho.
104009 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
25 / M / This Dying World
Offline
Posted 1/6/15

kaname08 wrote:


AnimeKami wrote:


kaname08 wrote:

I still want Inaho alive in the second season, he better be there with his emotionless character lol


OOO hai!


Lelouch


Yes? lol
7565 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
19 / M / California
Offline
Posted 1/6/15


You forgot his best quote "This is war"

And also the stupid fans he got right now that ... in my opinion, doesn't really think about his characters, rather just how cool he is.
81839 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
26 / M
Online
Posted 1/6/15

PrincipeCapio wrote:

You forgot his best quote "This is war"

And also the stupid fans he got right now that ... in my opinion, doesn't really think about his characters, rather just how cool he is.


Ugh, I can't even remember much about Inaho other than how he was pretty much Mashiro from Sakurasou but with a "mechs talent" instead.
12047 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
53 / M
Offline
Posted 1/6/15

PrincipeCapio wrote:

If you're not planning to put wealth into this discussion, please move elsewhere troll.




A person who posts a rant that basically amounts to "I hate this character, I love this character, and anyone who doesn't agree with me is basically stupid" complains about trolling and not putting anything into a "discussion"?
4193 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
34 / M
Offline
Posted 1/6/15 , edited 1/6/15

PrincipeCapio wrote:
He's not a gary stu like Inaho, he's the embodiment of a teenager. He did what he could to protect the princess through his own choices, he thought he could trust people like the emperor but was betrayed? Is that a stupid decision? No because most people would do this as well. He tried to get help from the samurai guy. Is that a stupid decision? No, because Slaine is all alone in the Martian world and desperation can well fit in.

I'm gonna log for the night, I'll be free to defend my position tomorrow but so far things looking bad, everyone is simply sharing their shallow thinking here especially those who admit they like gary stu characters just because.

Yes, let's conveniently sidestep the parts where people have problems with Slaine and bring up the parts where people really don't complain about.

And you're the one who brought up episode 7 and now you're running away. Well go ahead and sleep... take your time... when you wake up let's see what you have to say for episode 7 that hasn't been said yet. Although I'm pretty sure you have nothing new to add to the whole episode 7 debacle.


Derekl1963 wrote:


PrincipeCapio wrote:

If you're not planning to put wealth into this discussion, please move elsewhere troll.




A person who posts a rant that basically amounts to "I hate this character, I love this character, and anyone who doesn't agree with me is basically stupid" complains about trolling and not putting anything into a "discussion"?

IKR.
40319 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
23 / M / Free World Jail
Offline
Posted 1/6/15

Demimaelstrom wrote:


PrincipeCapio wrote:

You forgot his best quote "This is war"

And also the stupid fans he got right now that ... in my opinion, doesn't really think about his characters, rather just how cool he is.


Ugh, I can't even remember much about Inaho other than how he was pretty much Mashiro from Sakurasou but with a "mechs talent" instead.


You smart. You VERY smart. Matter a fact, you're a genius.
20283 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
http://myanimelis...
Offline
Posted 1/6/15

AnimeKami wrote:


kaname08 wrote:


AnimeKami wrote:


kaname08 wrote:

I still want Inaho alive in the second season, he better be there with his emotionless character lol


OOO hai!


Lelouch


Yes? lol


Lol my eyes are failing me >.> I read ooo hail *facepalm*
Hai hai wut ish up? XD
7565 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
19 / M / California
Offline
Posted 1/6/15 , edited 1/6/15

Derekl1963 wrote:


PrincipeCapio wrote:

If you're not planning to put wealth into this discussion, please move elsewhere troll.




A person who posts a rant that basically amounts to "I hate this character, I love this character, and anyone who doesn't agree with me is basically stupid" complains about trolling and not putting anything into a "discussion"?


Shutdown , I need to sleep but it's merely because of his comment, I was expecting more of a like to where I can defend my position but instead I got a reply that is completely unrelated to the whole thing.

To kaname & lelouch dude: this isn't a chat for you two
2904 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
26
Offline
Posted 1/6/15


First, I would NOT rescue the person who told me straight to my face that he was trying to kill the person I've been through hell trying to rescue and protect. I am not that stupid.

Secondly, I see nothing wrong with enjoying someone who uses their intelligence to overcome a disadvantage instead of the just-in-time power-ups or preservering through sheer willpower and determination. Also, the only one I remember him beating single-handedly is the final boss guy. Every other time, he was surrounded by allies who assisted him.

Thirdly, I personally think Inaho is much more emotionally than people give him credit for but that could vary depending on how you interpret the scenes.


I agree with everything you said here.

I also agree with the OP to a certain extent. I forget on what points exactly haha it's getting too late; my brain's just gone by now.

Don't shoot me but I like Inaho better. I think what's really missing is his back story which would explain why he's so unemotional. Maybe I like him better just because I'm rather unemotional most of the time. Also, Inaho resembles my 17 year old cousin. He's also calm and deadpan most of the time. He's a very strict and disciplined kid who rarely ever wavers in stressful situations. He's also brilliant and has a wide breadth of knowledge.

Anyway, I think if they made Inaho at least show flickers of when he's finally reached his breaking point, it would've been more realistic. Even the most calm people do break down at some point in time.

81839 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
26 / M
Online
Posted 1/6/15

GoldTStar wrote:

You smart. You VERY smart. Matter a fact, you're a genius.




40319 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
23 / M / Free World Jail
Offline
Posted 1/6/15

PrincipeCapio wrote:


Derekl1963 wrote:


PrincipeCapio wrote:

If you're not planning to put wealth into this discussion, please move elsewhere troll.




A person who posts a rant that basically amounts to "I hate this character, I love this character, and anyone who doesn't agree with me is basically stupid" complains about trolling and not putting anything into a "discussion"?


Shutdown , I need to sleep but it's merely because of his comment, I was expecting more of a like to where I can defend my position but instead I got a reply that is completely unrelated to the whole thing.

To kaname & lelouch dude: this isn't a chat for you two


You should've been around when the "Best Guy/Girl" tournaments launched.
First  Prev  1  2  3  4  Next  Last
You must be logged in to post.