Post Reply Ororo Iqadi Munroe (Storm) vs Misaka Mikoto (Railgun)
18663 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
36 / M / Small Wooded town...
Offline
Posted 1/23/15 , edited 1/23/15
This thread is not for "fan-tards" that do not know how to debate.

This thread is a vs debate where we point out the evidence and deliberate with each other over the facts that bring you to your educated hypothesis explaining why and how you come to choose who would survive in a all out fight against each other.

Ororo Iqadi Munroe (Storm)





vs...



Misaka Mikoto (Railgun)



Let the battle begin!
18663 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
36 / M / Small Wooded town...
Offline
Posted 1/24/15
I do understand that such topics that require a debate is not much liked in the GF that is why we so indeed need a ED. But we do not have an ED, so I fear that this topic will have to be in the GF.

Rules & reminders.. This is a Debate, not a what is your favorite character discussion. So to keep on topic please bring some general knowledge of the characters as you make your case on who would most likely win.
13650 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
こ ~ じ ~ か
Offline
Posted 1/24/15
Might be wrong, but Storm's power isn't just lightning but rather weather in general.

Proceeding on that basis, Storm has more flexibility than Biri-Biri. As a member of the X-Men, she also would very likely have much greater physical prowess and more combat experience than middle-schooler Misaka.

Assuming also that Storm knew the nature of Misaka's powers it is doubtful she would employ lightning against her, since Biri-Biri could just turn it back on her or deflect it. If she didn't she'd learn really quick. Storm would use the weather, in combination with her powers of flight, to create an advantageous field for herself and beat Biri-Biri into submission.

On the other hand, I doubt Storm could overcome the combination of Kuroko+Misaka+Touma that would inevitably result from her domination of the fight.
18663 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
36 / M / Small Wooded town...
Offline
Posted 1/24/15

evilotakuneko wrote:

Might be wrong, but Storm's power isn't just lightning but rather weather in general.

Proceeding on that basis, Storm has more flexibility than Biri-Biri. As a member of the X-Men, she also would very likely have much greater physical prowess and more combat experience than middle-schooler Misaka.

Assuming also that Storm knew the nature of Misaka's powers it is doubtful she would employ lightning against her, since Biri-Biri could just turn it back on her or deflect it. If she didn't she'd learn really quick. Storm would use the weather, in combination with her powers of flight, to create an advantageous field for herself and beat Biri-Biri into submission.

On the other hand, I doubt Storm could overcome the combination of Kuroko+Misaka+Touma that would inevitably result from her domination of the fight.


That is a good start, so I play devils advocate at this time. Biri-Biri as lovingly call her, it is true she lacks experience, and wile she lacks power in say wind, fog, and ice. She makes up for it in he ability to control not only lightning but creating magnetized fields witch she can easily allow her to manipulate metals, such as he iron sand storm, her Iron sand sword, and her Rail Gun in witch she has been given the nickname of. allowing her to utilize both ranged and melee fighting styles. This in it self would put her at par with storms powers over other elements.
At that Her Rail gun has been shown to be strong enough to pierce through solid metal posts used for construction. This may indeed give the young lady the edge over her opponent (storm).
9407 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
26 / M / UK
Offline
Posted 1/24/15
I really think this would be decided by the battlefield. A battle in a place like Academy City would give Biri-Biri buildings to magnetize herself to, and plenty of shrapnel to fire at the Weather-Witch. It would also grant some degree of protection from the elements. A wide open space on the other hand would leave her defenseless against the weather, and stuck on the ground.

Anyone have a battlefield in mind?
18663 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
36 / M / Small Wooded town...
Offline
Posted 1/25/15

BladeGunner wrote:

I really think this would be decided by the battlefield. A battle in a place like Academy City would give Biri-Biri buildings to magnetize herself to, and plenty of shrapnel to fire at the Weather-Witch. It would also grant some degree of protection from the elements. A wide open space on the other hand would leave her defenseless against the weather, and stuck on the ground.

Anyone have a battlefield in mind?


Battle field would be the danger room in the X-Mens school and home base. That way they could adjust the background they are fighting in the give both some level of equal footing.
Posted 1/25/15 , edited 1/25/15

Darkphoenix3450 wrote:

I do understand that such topics that require a debate is not much liked in the GF that is why we so indeed need a ED. But we do not have an ED, so I fear that this topic will have to be in the GF.

Rules & reminders.. This is a Debate, not a what is your favorite character discussion. So to keep on topic please bring some general knowledge of the characters as you make your case on who would most likely win.


You're such a cynic. The Crurnchyroll forums aren't that bad.

Plus, I'm not sure if this is such an appropriate topic for ED.

Back on topic, could Storm somehow lead Mikoto inside? Could Mikoto lead Storm inside? I don't have knowledge of either candidate, but I believe this is an important factor.
7523 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
17 / M / Crimson Mage Village
Offline
Posted 1/25/15 , edited 1/25/15
Mikoto is less top-heavy = superiority in battle.


-Although, regardless of their powers, etc., MikoMikorin~ is still a child, and doesn't yet have the resolve to take another's life, even for survival. So, if it really came down to that...
169 cr points
Send Message: Send PM GB Post
41 / M
Offline
Posted 1/25/15 , edited 1/25/15
Pitting any Marvel comics character against a non-Marvel comics character is absurd because Marvel comics is absurd.

Let's take some quotes:

Storm has been stated to be a possible Omega-Level Mutant. Her potential is as of yet unrealized, and on one occasion the Super Giant stated that Storm was an "Omega-Level Mutate", grouping and targeting her with Omega-Level mutants such as Iceman and Rachel Grey.


Storm is an expert thief, and a skilled, cunning and gifted hand-to-hand fighter, trained by Achmed el-Gibar, Professor X, Wolverine and T'Challa, the Black Panther. By using superior strategy, Storm has overcome physically stronger foes like Callisto and the Crimson Commando in hand-to-hand combat. Storm is an excellent marksman with handguns, and is proficient in the use of knives. Storm is also fluent in Russian, Arabic and Swahili. As part of her paraphernalia, Storm carries a set of lock-picks (with which she has an extraordinary ability at picking locks, in an early appearance she was able to pick a lock with her teeth while her physical coordination was reduced to the level of an infant) and her ancestral ruby, which allows inter-dimensional transportation with the help of her lightning.


So, yeah, if you can reduce her physical coordination to baby level, she can still pick a lock with her teeth...


On a separate note, it has been stated that Storm's spirit is so strong that she was able to host the consciousness of an avatar (or "manifestation body") of Eternity; in a gathering consisting of herself, Doctor Strange, Black Panther, Silver Surfer and the Fantastic Four, she and Doctor Strange were the only viable candidates.


Her magic potential rivals the greatest human magic user in the Marvel universe.

I'm not going to quote the whole section on her powers, but I'll summarize: she can fly, can become nearly invisible, can instantly flash freeze people, can shoot out whirlwinds/tornados, can control air pressure so well that she can cause people to suffocate, and can control electromagnetic fields, cosmic storms, solar wind, and ocean currents.

Also, she's a master tactician who generally ends up in charge when Cyclops is unavailable.

It's not a fair fight because Storm is an absurd character.
You must be logged in to post.