If you have seen Soul eater and like it, you will like Blood lad.
All the Bakemonogatari series.
If you like Spice And Wolf, you would love Maoyuu Maou Yuusha.
Cringiest series you ever will see in your life. Watashi ga Motenai no wa Dou Kangaetemo Omaera ga Warui!.
Do not let the beginning fool you and drop it. Saying more than that is bad spoilers. From the New World.
I think any person who loves anime should a less watch this shows once in their lives. Aishiteruze Baby and Usagi Drop and Non Non Biyori
Most random show I have ever seen in my life. Nichijou
Is fuck up. Another.
Don't expect season 2. Btooom!
Heart rape. Casshern Sins
Fuck your feels. Plastic Memories
If you like Spice And wolf this may be your thing. C: The Money of Soul and Possibility Control
Weird. Gankutsuou: The Count of Monte Cristo
Rather fight superman than to be ever stuck in this anime world. Monster
Hey, don't give me that look and just try before judging me.Free! - Iwatobi Swim Club
Because why the fuck no? I enjoy the fights. Etotama
Maybe you like or hate it, I don't know but I think you should try it out. Eve no Jikan
More dead serieus than one would assume. And if you pay close attention to certain episodes, your heart may even break.Gugure! Kokkuri-san
I enjoy it. Hagure Yuusha no Estetica
Umm really good I think. Gatchaman Crowds Insight
Food porn. Gourmet Girl Graffiti
Man this shows is brutal. Freezing
I hate people who use big words just to make themselves look perspicacious.
Box of Goblins
The Skull Man
Ryoko's Case Files
Ground Control to Psycho-electric Girl
The Severing Crime Edge
Okami Kakushi: Masque of the Wolf
In Search of the Real Future
Beyond the Boundary
A Good Librarian Like a Good Shepherd
A Sunday Without God
Favorite anime list at http://www.anime-planet.com/users/Reddawnrocker/anime/...
Since your watching the monogatari series watch it in this order
Monogatari: Second Season
All are on CR except for Koyomimonogatari and for reference CR does not have the last three episodes of Bakemonogatari
Did you know everytime you sigh, you let a little bit of happiness escape?
I am a long time Anime fan I've completed 100s of series. I've watched so many Anime that I can't even remember the names of them all to make a proper list. If it's anything you would see on any Top Anime list or Anime Recommendation list or video I've probably seen it. I'm looking for something good (or even decent) that's off the beaten path. I've long left behind the idea of a preferred genre.
Here's a rough list of what I can remember off the top of my head there is a ton missing, but it's probably better than not providing anything.
Please if you could give me your best shot.
Kanon 2006 (haven't watched the first version yet so can't say anything about that one)
Myself ; Yourself
Nabari no Ou
My Bride is a Mernaid
We Without Wings
The Tower of Druaga
The Fruit of Grisaia
Fate/Kaleid Liner Prisma Illya
Is it Wrong to Try to Pick Up Girls in a Dungeon?!
H2o: Footprints in the Sand
A couple of these are pretty popular but none of them are on your list. And they're all things that are defintely worth at least giving a try.
"I'm actually a masochist."
These are some good but not necessarily popular anime. Some might be hard to find as they are older.
Shin Sekai Yori
Not on Crunchy:
Tokyo Magnitude 8.0
Witch Hunter Robin
There's a few. Hope something in there helps.
New anime I like
KABANERI OF THE IRON FORTRESS just had 6 new episodes. Check it out... where can we request for it to be streamed here?
Ni hao ma!
It's really good action/drama/comedy, a bit of ecchi, romance. It's about a boy who's been framed for a murder and he has to prove his innocence, with several superpowered factions chasing after him, plus having their own conflicts.
It's not on Crunchy but it's on Hulu and Netflix. hulu.com/k The title is just one letter.
these are some of my faves. Like you I have been watching anime to long to have a certain kind I like. more then likely many of these you have seen. most of these are my fall back anime I watch when... there is nothing good that came out.
Hajime No Ippo best boxing anime ever
Ai Yori Aoshi
Zone of the Ender
Starship Operators. really liked this one
Robotech.... my kick off into total anime freak.
Hand Maid May.
Full metal Panic and full metal Alchemist
The Third the girl with the blue eye
Azu Manga Daioh
Banner of the stars. with this one I cant remember is Banner or Crest of the Stars cam first
Bubblegum Crisis and 2040 one
Beck Mongolian Chop Squad
His and her Circumstance
Battle Athletes Victory both series
Oh! My goddess
I thought mal could suggest series. Don't give up watching anime!
A few I recommend
I Can't Understand What My Husband Is Saying
Tanaka-kun is always Listless
Just to put things into perspective there some old timer anime fans who have watched thousands of anime.