In the hopes of being of help, I'm not going to pull any punches and rate this series a 5 because I thought it was "okay." I'm going to be as honest as I can get about each aspect.
The title
La Corda d'Oro is not French, as sometimes thought, but Italian. It can be loosely translated as
the golden string but what it actually means is
The Golden Bond, as in a priceless bond. This is important to the whole story concept.
It lasts for only one season. The
secondo passo is not a season, as the subtitle implies, but a special.
GENERAL OVERVIEW:
La Corda d'Oro is based on a romance RPG by KOEI. The title refers to the eventual bond of friendship between the main character, Hino Kahoko, and the friends she meets during her musical adventure. In a wider sense, the title also refers to the bond between her heart and her magical violin (which works as a mirror into her being) and so, also refers to the human soul and music. On the surface, the phrase translated as a synonym,
the golden string, literally refers to the golden string used on her violin. It's a brilliant title. Unfortunately, the title is the deepest thing about the series.
While it shares surface features with
Nodame Cantabile,
Kaleido Star,
Glass Mask,
HoneyxClover, and even
Snow Fairy Sugar, it is, to use a phrase often uttered in the show itself, "Not of that level." If you enjoy anime about the arts, or so called harems, you might just like this series. However, if what you want is a deep slice of life romance with the emotion of
Honey and Clover, or a philosophical story about the performing arts, like
Glass Mask, this is neither. If you have never seen any of the above, I would recommend watching any of those first.
Above all,
La Corda d'Oro most seriously disappoints because it doesn't know what it's supposed to be. A romance? A coming of age? A supernatural mystery? A slice of life about artists? A magical girl series? In not deciding what it is it misses the boat on all of them, and, other than overwhelming boredom, I felt overwhelming disappointment at the loss of potential.
STORYLINE:
La Corda d'Oro is most like
Snow Fairy Sugar. Both portray a schoolgirl who, with the help of a spirit friend, finds her true self through the music she loves. Unlike
Snow Fairy Sugar, which had a very strong storyline despite the apparent childishness of the series, the theme isn't grasped strongly. This title was not fleshed out properly in order to be a feature show. The supernatural background of the school and its founder is never discussed. The character of Lili/Riri, the music spirit, never becomes more than an excuse to start the show. The lead character is not required to overcome poverty, as in
Snow Fairy Sugar, or loneliness because of the loss of her family, as in
Fruits Basket. Nor is she required to succeed despite being clueless and making disastrous errors, as in
Kaleido Star ... Neither is this series about her one big shot to fulfill a life need despite hardship, as in
Glass Mask,
Kaleido Star, or
Honey and Clover.
Other weaknesses aside, the script's biggest problems are pacing and focus. Instead of following a likely pattern of introduction, slow build-up, big reveal, deeper evolution, second big reveal, then grand close,
La Corda d'Oro languishes in a series of halfhearted episodes and unrealized issues. Each of the 26 Episodes drag up to a moment of possible importance, then end. It's as if the only purpose of the show was to pull the game events out into an 11 hour story without adding anything else to the script. Maybe that's what happened.
The morale to the story, that music should be viewed as an expression of the soul and should be enjoyed, is not well focused. The romance (and this is a romance title if nothing else) is incredibly weak.
Wishy-washy would be a good term since there is virtually no real love at all. For that matter, there's no real tenderness or friendship. Character interaction is awkward and it seems as if this lack of emotion is unintentional.
As if to own up to this, Ep 26, a recap, exists only to punch through the romance idea in a "very special epilogue." This episode itself is like a 20 minute romance RPG where each character is given a few minutes in their special romantic setting.
** Spoiler Alert!!! click to hide or show**
Yet again, absolutely nothing happens -- and a weird nothing. As if each of these characters were not only devoid of soul, but robots turned off before they finished their task.
The special bond between Kahoko and her friends is similarly wishy-washy. We are never really shown why any of these characters are ever drawn to each other at all other than being in the same location at the same time. And that's the main failing of the script -- that it tells rather than shows, which, for a visual program, makes for a very confusing story. The big turning in the middle of the series, which thankfully begins to set the story on a more natural rail, makes no sense because we see no emotion behind it. In retrospect, it can be understood as one of the characters telling Kahoko she is a failure if she cannot own up to her own emotions, and that this makes her both an unattractive person and an unattractive competitor. However, I just said this 100 times better than the anime. The way this plays out is so weak, viewers are left wondering what happened, what the big deal was, and why the characters are all so upset. Even the characters themselves wonder.
Characters being upset is another issue. There is a lot of whining in this series, and not about various things -- about the same things over and over, and for no real reason. We do not know why Kahoko is so upset when the spirit of music has explained very clearly to her why she shouldn't be upset, but, if she didn't remain upset, the only thin conflict in the story would go away. Sadly, in keeping the conflict going, she betrays the actual concept of the story -- that she has the spirit of music inside of her and has been chosen to bring it to all who surround her.
This is supposed to be why everyone loves her -- because they sense something special and free about her spirit -- but we don't ever really see this. We see a lot of moping. Speaking of
Kaleido Star, the main character Kahoko is just as redundant as Sora, but where Sora's repetition is in her upbeat nature (and thus easy to forgive), Kahoko is redundant in her continual whining when the only problem she has is being patroned by a spirit of music.
If a series of conflicts had been introduced through character development the script could have had ample opportunity to show Kahoko as the charming girl who thrives in the face of adversity. Instead, we are expected to believe that's who she is because this is supposed to be that sort of story. Imagine
Fruits Basket gone terribly wrong. I gave the script a "bad" rating instead of "horrible" because if you pay attention, you can see what the story was supposed to be doing. However, IMHO, this script needed to be thrown out and completely rewritten to be effective. It's almost as if the writers were so against introducing any conflict or weakness they were willing to shoot their own series in the foot.
CHARACTERS:
The characters serve their purpose. They are what you expect from a harem, but disappointingly, only that. There is the scattered main character -- a normal, yet somehow uniquely brilliant person who we see coming out of her/his shell. There's the comforting friend character. The un-threatening, energetic character. The superficial mannered one who can never find a place to be themselves. The cool "tsundere." The wilting flower with an iron soul. There's even the nosy school journalist side-character who winds up saying something encouraging.
What makes some romance series exciting is how these stock parts only remain so until after the initial introduction, developing into unique characters as the story evolves. In
La Corda d'Oro there is no development like this. Not for lack of time or chance but simply because the script chooses to bring up possible conflict after possible conflict and ignore each. If character development isn't that important to you, then this might not be a problem. Be forewarned, however -- if you are bored or frustrated at episode 4 or 5, that feeling won't change.
The people who surround Kahoko love her instantly (because they are supposed to) and are all upset when she becomes upset (because they are supposed to be). There doesn't seem to be a sensible reason they all begin to lose themselves in sadness. We are shown no reason why this "bond" exists. The most bizarre example of this is
** Spoiler Alert!!! click to hide or show**
Yunoki Azuma, who suddenly and without much prior time on screen reveals his sadistic inner nature to Kahoko. This is supposed to be him relaxing in front of her because he trusts her above all others, yet, not only is there no build up to this, there is very, very little of it ever shown at all. Azuma is on screen so little that when, at the end of the series, he tells her (in his own special way) she is his favorite person to be around, we are left wondering what episodes we missed. The only thing that keeps the transformation from being completely nonsensical is that you know it's bound to happen ... because that's his character.
A similar example is
** Spoiler Alert!!! click to hide or show**
Tsuchiura Ryotaro, the comforting friend with the mysterious past who overcomes his weaknesses with Hino's help. Neither is his past that mysterious nor does Hino actually do much directly to inspire him, but, that is his character. Despite being the most fleshed out of any of the characters, he appears, then spends a large amount of time forgotten. This is a terrible waste, especially since his predicament mirrors the series concept very closely.
MUSIC:
In a series like this, the music, characters, and story should be so closely tied as to echo one another. Japanese animation usually excels at this, but here, ironically, it doesn't really work out. There is an attempt to define story arcs by themes used in the school competition, but I frequently found myself forgetting what the selection theme was supposed to be as Kahoko wandered around in the meantime. The music itself fades in both presentation and purpose. Many of the episodes in between the selections are taken up by procrastination; saying they don't know what to play, talking about practicing, talking about not practicing, shopping, crying, and so on.
The pieces each character plays for the selections are questionable. Some pieces are too literal in a series where the music students express their superior ability to "get it." Some are downright unsuitable for the characters. Yes, these are musical pieces that have remained popular for hundreds of years so they're all going to be excellent anyway, but isn't that a little lazy? The choices should have been used to broaden the characters. Here again,
** Spoiler Alert!!! click to hide or show**
Ryotaro
is a great example.
** Spoiler Alert!!! click to hide or show**
A prodigy added to the contest late when his surprising gifts are revealed, Ryotaro only plays Chopin. At first, I thought this was part of the story, that part of his weakness was that he didn't like to play anything else ... That he would finally be docked points for only playing Chopin and conflict would arise. But this was only because the director seemed unwilling to pick any other music for piano than Chopin. Ryo finally plays a Liszt piece at the end of the series, thank goodness.
Each piece is cut so short as to provide us with little time to do anything but see the cut scenes of a crowd, and while they're still wonderful pieces, the anime does no justice by selecting only the most well known of well known pieces then cutting them to oblivion.
The Opening and Ending themes are okay. The opening is sweet pop. The song grows on you. The ending theme is forgettable and not appropriate or enjoyable, IMHO. I'm sure there are other tracks being played in the background but if so, these are also forgettable.
ANIMATION:
Viewers seem to either love it or hate it. I think it's ... average. It's not terrible, but reused scenes get tiresome, the expressions are lacking and at many times flat, and most disappointingly, a fantastic opportunity for some technical animation went ignored. This could have been the music series to end all music series. The rendering and animation of the instruments and fingerings alone could have been so much more exquisite and been a real highlight of the entire production. In a way, that this opportunity went unused is just another facet of the series not being what it could have been -- an emotional series about the life of musicians.