« Back to Katana vs. Rapier

Katana vs. Rapier Comments
  • Prev  1  2  3  Next
  • 1/14/11
    yinfire
    The samuria didn't win. The rapier did a much better job. If this was a real fight, the rapier would have slashed him open.
  • 12/2/10
    autumnanime
    uhh way too fake and slow... =="
  • 7/14/10
    nab2000
    Fail. Too many openings for the rapier to slash him open. >.<
  • 7/13/10
    nogard
    at least samurai won.. thats good already ^^
  • 7/13/10
    nogard
    fail... if i would be samurai, i would have so many open hits to deal to rapier... he failed so many..
  • 7/11/10
    crazy_wasabii
    samurais ForTheWin!!!
  • 7/6/10
    stupid_loser_girl92
    I like samurais and katanas better. Fight should've been more violent.
  • 7/3/10
    videling
    Wow that is a sure like! I'm searched there for Shrek and Himura Kenshin behind them
  • 7/2/10
    lisnoire
    SakuraMishimoto - Sound added for effect. They don't sound like that. lovehater22 - I've seen far better rapier fighters. Choreography was way off. kboiipop - True.
  • 7/2/10
    lisnoire
    Burchwood - Wrong. The Portuguese established trade with Japan in 1540's. The rapier was the primary weapon of the nobility. They did have wheel lock firearms but they were limited in availability and unreliable. SakuraMishimoto - Sou
  • 7/2/10
    hottgirl101
    hahaha lol!
  • 7/2/10
    caisweet
    its like puss 'n boots vs. a bad ninja :p
  • 7/2/10
    kaiyukichan
    I have to agree with Dakduif. The guy with the katana looks like he's better.
  • 7/1/10
    Karkarov
    Sort of more like a soul caliber fan video than anything. In a real sword fight the more skilled fighter always wins, what kind of sword they are using rarely has anything to do with it.
  • 7/1/10
    haruhichan16
    awesome,i love fights with different skills ^^
  • 7/1/10
    Dakduif
    Katana guy looks a little bit more like he knows what he's doing than rapier guy.. :/
  • 6/30/10
    kboiipop
    On par with fighters of similar skill and experience, rapier wins over katana. I will not technically explain to you morons who keep thinking katanas are superior over other melee weapons. I thought the same at first.( I own a katana.
  • 6/30/10
    Bunnygirl808
    lol sound effects..
  • 6/30/10
    Beld
    Anyone else think that this would have lasted maybe 20 seconds at most before one or both managed to get a Kill Strike in?
  • 6/29/10
    lovehater22
    rapid guy's steps were wrong and position were wrong, wasn;t even holding it right, idk about katana guy, but he looks really cool
  • 6/29/10
    lovehater22
    i must said rapier guy is terrible
  • 6/27/10
    Blaze75
    a katana is a killer weapon and parrying with a rapier isnt rly smart xD i would say tie cuz if ur rly good with a rapier ur quick n u dodge well but having a katana u get killed easly xD
  • 6/25/10
    omnifish
    the description made me excited to watch the vid then the level of how scripted it was killed that excitement
  • 6/25/10
    SakuraMishimoto
    Personally, I love Katana, but you can't get past the "whiiip" sound the Rapier makes. 8D
  • 6/24/10
    Burchwood
    @kpopberserker: what are you talking about? by the time europe found japan they where past the melee age and into the gun age of weapons so you can't say they where always better because the type of weapons where completely different, idiot
  • 6/24/10
    Burchwood
    they guy with the rapier doesn't know how to use his weapon. he should be using evasive steps with thrusts used through out. and you NEVER parry with a rapier, you will end up dead with a broken weapon...
  • 6/22/10
    Asobitaii
    Katanas are better. http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main the Rule of Cool.
  • 6/22/10
    hm1
    WHO WON??????
  • 6/22/10
    KaoriYatsura
    I'm sorry the rapier would have broken long before then.
  • 6/22/10
    kpopberserker
    ill tell you this the only thing europe had on asia at the time was gunpowder we owned them in all the melee battles
  • 6/22/10
    purpleraj
    fencing ftw XD
  • 6/22/10
    mj_buena
    I always wondered why can't samurai's trip over their long skirts
  • 6/22/10
    Sagiel
    Its like me and my buddy, but he uses an axe and I a Saber.
  • 6/22/10
    Denethal
    Katana is for cutting, Rapier is for stabbing and thrusting... two different things.
  • 6/22/10
    dinho123
    THEY STOLE THE ORIGINAL SOUNDTRACK FROM FROM THE ANIME BLOOD+
  • 6/22/10
    HiYaBaby1
    katana is the best O.O
  • 6/22/10
    plainknights
    Lol this sh*t is lame
  • 6/22/10
    BaraTwoswords
    Please, types of swords don't mean anything. It is 100% the skill of the person using them. This clip is just mental masturbation by escapist idiots. Expert sword users mostly have agreed the katana is the best all around cutting weapon.
  • 6/22/10
    hannasonne
    nice, but also a bit lame. Samurai's gonna win.
  • 6/22/10
    PeriGrinnss
    The katana's first move was three overhead strikes blocked by the rapier "clang clang clang" that would have broken the rapier the first time metal hit metal. Then they do a nice high five clanging swords again. It's cute but that's all.
  • 6/22/10
    InsertSomethingCleverHere
    My point? The real thing would be a lot less visually interesting, with lots of posturing and feints and a quick finish. This was over-polished choreography right down to the finish.
  • 6/22/10
    InsertSomethingCleverHere
    The smart Katana user knows the Rapier is fast but flimsy. He would stay out of pin-cushion range until he could get a good solid hit--and a Katana can thrust too. Just a hit on the opponent's sword arm would be enough to decide it.
  • 6/22/10
    Alkamos
    A katana would rape a rapier.
  • 6/22/10
    InsertSomethingCleverHere
    In a real duel, there's no way in Hell a Rapier-style user is going to parry a heavier slashing blade, he'd stay out of range and come in when he had an opening for a vital spot like an eye, throat, heart. Rapier has a long, quick reach.
  • 6/22/10
    puppyhouse
    okay what happened ???whos the winner????
  • 6/22/10
    Gustbabels
    He doesn't have a rapier- he has a foil, which he's brutally abusing. If he did have a rapier, though, the katana would win, because it's lighter and faster.
  • 6/22/10
    aWatcher
    i dont know why that rapier guy is trying to slash his opponent when his rapier a stabbing weapon.
  • 6/22/10
    noureddine
    NICEEEEEE!!!!!!! but fake......XD
  • Prev  1  2  3  Next