The anime is... cute. The protagonist was a little stupid but he was also a super nice kid. Had that, "Altruistic hero that never gives up!" vibe going for him. I've seen it before. It didn't give me anything new but hey, I'm here to watch a Shonen anime. I don't have especially high standards when it comes to a series meant for kids. The world is fun the characters are quirky and the plot is simple enough where I can be brain dead and follow along without exerting much effort. It's meh but a good way to pass time.

Then I read the manga. Now I won't watch the anime ever again. It's not an honest adaptation whatsoever. Anime and Manga Seth are NOTHING ALIKE. Yes, they have the same character design and the animation IS itself really good... but manga Seth doesn't smile THAT much. He's actually angry a lot, justifiably so. His motives and pain feels more real to me than anime Seth, who felt more like a "main character" fill in for a new anime series.

As of me writing this, the anime is at it's ninth episode and the manga at it's seventeenth chapter. That is NOT enough space between productions to start an anime and it shows. What I thought was just bland writing was actually FILLER. Black Clover was given ridiculous amounts of hate for their few episodes of filler and the Radiant anime has sooooo much more.

Spoilers.

This review is after watching ALL of season 1. I wouldn't say this anime is a 10/10 show, especially since the start felt too much like a basic shonen. But... a little further along, it starts to grow on me. I thought it was just going to be one of those 'oh he's op, gonna beat every baddy with the power of desire/motivation blah blah blah' kind of shows... but stuff actually happens and there are actual feels further on in the season/it's not quite so simple. I'm glad I kept up with this show instead of dropping it like originally intended. (btw, notice how like 90% of the people giving the show less than 3 stars are saying the manga is better?.... the show standing alone is decent though.) 'Bout to go read the manga though cuz of those reviews...

I was a bit excited about this show based on how it started. There's a world with magic, but those who are able to use are seen as monsters, for they survived and encounter with humanity's main nemesis. The protagonist has a very clearly defined goal: to find Radiant, the place where these odd creatures come from, in order to destroy it and prevent nemesis from invading and destroying humankind.

Even after seeing first-hand how normal humans mistreat Seth (the protagonist) and Alba (his mentor and mother-figure), we get an even more heart-wrenching moment on the third episode in Alba's flashback as we see young Seth being beaten and almost killed by humans who saw him as a monster simply because he has horns and can do magic. That episode really made me feel for these characters, and it was impressing that Seth was a good person who, despite all that he has suffered at the hands of normal people, still wants to protect them.

By contrast, we see in the second episode that there are magicians who do not have the same outlook as Seth and Alba, and who want to take advantage on normal humans, as well as seek revenge. That duality really made the world of Radiant more relatable and interesting.

Alas, that is where it all stopped. After the third episode the show took a deep dive into nonsense. Seth meets members of the Inquisition, who appear to be the antagonists who pursue and seek to eliminate sorcerers. "Why?" you ask. The so far (episode 6) the show's answer is "just because." There isn't a concrete reason for the Inquisition to hunt down sorcerers indiscriminately. It would make sense if they only went after wrong-doers. However, they arrest the naive Seth who could not control his broom and "crashed" into the Inquisition's ship. They had arrested Melie (the red-haired witch) because she did not have her documents with her. And I believe they were going to arrest Doc because he was carrying the remainders of a Nemesis.

In the first couple of episodes the show clearly sets that sorcerers are the only ones who fight the Nemesis. Not once did the show state that the Inquisition does likewise, only that it is out to get sorcerers for no reason. That is simply not a good way of building up the world. Having a villain with no real motive is boring. Sure, the Nemesis are monsters that destroy everything in their way, but, so far, they seem to be mindless creatures. The Inquisition, however, only seems to be out to get all sorcerers, despite the fact that they are the only ones able to protect humanity from the Nemesis.

Also, from the fourth episode forward everyone becomes incredibly one-dimensional and over-the-top idiotic. Those in the Inquisition boat seem incompetent of handling two young magicians and a goofy human. Then they arrive at the flying wizard mecca of Artemis Academy, which Doc forces Seth to become a citizen, knowing fully-well that that will cause Seth to be in enormous debt, which will be transferred to Doc as he had already gone through that process with Melie. Sure, it was very interesting when the cat leader of Artemis brought out the city's defense against the Inquisition, but that's about it. Everything in that town is incredibly goofy for its own sake. Melie, Seth, and Doc all become extravagantly wacky, boisterous, and unbearable to watch.

At the end of episode six, Yaga, whom Alma sent Seth to encounter, decides to take Seth as a pupil, for we know that he is special. It seems like the show may or may not get better, but so far it has been incredibly disappointing, especially after such a great set up.

TL;DR first three-episodes gave hope of a good series, but the show ultimately falls flat on one-dimensional characters and over-the-top tropes

Well first of i was a little skeptical about this and the first few episodes i was starting to give up on the anime but if you grin the first few episodes the anime actually is very much enjoyable the story at first was a bit dragging on my opinion. The main character is funny and he has a very interesting background lots of mysteries about his past, the anime it self is funny and the more episodes you go through the anime is beginning to go even more interesting, the animation is very good and the soundtracks aswell and the story line is super interesting and exicting cant wait to see this animes full potential when people become to realize how good this anime actually is, the anime is like mixing One Piece and Fairy Tail. I very much enjoy this anime and highly reccomend it to anybody else.

Haven't read the manga.

Genuinely struggled through the first half of s1 as it got a bit too Sunday morning cartoony for me but it picks up and manages to develop some maturity. Animation is really nice and the main character develops some depth.

Lots of mysterious aspects to the plot which leaves you hoping for more!!

If you can make it through the mid part of s1 you're in for a good ride!

Written after s2 ep4.

Hope it helps!

No reason to go on and on about this one. Putting it simply; it is a complete bastardization of the manga and is absolutely not worth anyone's time. Read the manga for the good version of this story and of these characters.

The anime tells the story poorly; it is mostly filler BS that just makes things drag on entirely more mundanely and boringly than the manga by leaps and bounds. The characters aren't accurate in many cases to the manga versions of them, and arguably the manga's proper versions of their personalities and actions are far more entertaining, engaging, and/or interesting.

A lot of people comstaly compared it to the manga but the anime is just as good. What draws me into each episode are the characters. I’m genuinely interested in them both good and evil. So far I’m enjoying it . Although I have to admit that the first episode made me hesitate because it wasn’t that good, but now I’m glad I kept watching. There’s a some badass fights and some pretty cute Waifus too.???????? . I hope this show keeps improving with time.

Half way through season one, the main character has the dumbest idea of justice ever. Willfully naive and cares more about "feeling" like he did the right thing, then actually "doing" the right thing. Also he loses a lot of important fights in the beginning. He doesn't show any growth until the end of season 1.

After watching season 2, I can say the show got better. However, it went from crap to average. If your bored and have watched everything else, this ones meh.

I love Mellie's enormous red hair and split personality. She would do anything for her friends. She seems like she gets lonely at times, but she always tries her best. But Ocoho is so cool. She rides a dracoon (the cutest portmanteau ever). And she is written really well. She's more in charge of her own destiny and often makes decisions that run against what she's supposed to do. She could easily be the lead character or have her own spin-off.