Let's dig into how One Piece's unique team dynamics contribute to its greatness!
Hello everyone, and welcome back to Why It Works. Having now fully caught up on One Piece, I have resigned myself to merely thinking about One Piece most of the time, and reflecting on the finer points of the Straw Hats’ journey. This, in turn, led me to marvel again at how, though each new island has its own attractions, it is ultimately nearly impossible to have a bad time with the Straw Hats. I don’t need threats and stakes to enjoy time in One Piece; it’s rewarding just spending time on the Sunny, taking a break with the crew between adventures. This is a natural result of One Piece possessing such a compelling core cast — but even more than that, it’s because that core cast has such rich, diverse internal dynamics.
I’ve discussed before how One Piece could at times be framed as “K-ON! at sea,” given one of its greatest appeals is simply lounging around with the Straw Hats themselves. Rather than feeling like tonally discordant breaks in the action, peaceful moments in One Piece offer a moment to breathe and reassert the communal trust of the main crew. This appeal carries over to the more action-packed segments, as well. In One Piece, the idea of simply reuniting with crewmates can serve as a genuine emotional hook; not “I want to see this character fight,” but simply, “I want to see my friends again.”
Crafting a dynamic like that, where the character relationships are so appealing that they can become their own stakes, is a lot easier said than done. For some shows, even if a group is a team overall, it might be constructed of component parts who don’t really have any relationships with each other. If an adventure narrative constructs itself around one central protagonist, it can be easy to create a situation like this. All of the component members will possess a clear dynamic with that central protagonist, but not necessarily a rapport or friendship with the other members. In the worst cases, it can be hard to imagine some secondary characters within a larger group ever sharing a conversation together.
Seemingly effortless camaraderie among characters actually requires a great deal of storytelling effort as you dig into what motivates, entertains, or frustrates each character and find distinctive ways for them to express their personality toward each other. It also requires pacing and patience, as you must space out these evolving dynamics over time, allowing your cast to truly get to know each other. You don’t want to risk creating some sense of a “canned dynamic,” a go-to engagement that feels more performative than earnest (even One Piece verges on this with its simple Zoro/Sanji dynamic). Rather than contrived “setups and punchlines,” you want the rise and fall of comedy to emerge naturally from the authentic perspectives of the characters.
One Piece excels at this process and addresses the potential problem in a variety of ways. First off, the relationship between Luffy and his crew is already a unique twist on the concept of a team leader. Though Luffy’s shipmates believe in him, they also know he has poor judgment, a short attention span, and a tendency to shoot first and ask questions later. Because of this, there’s a unique sense of equality between the crewmates — Luffy isn’t “above” his teammates and they’ll frequently take him to task for his stupider decisions. He ranges from the group’s unshakeable rock to its goofy kid brother, feeling equally natural in both positions and undercutting any idea of an official command hierarchy with his movement up and down the ladder.
Other members of the crew develop distinct bonds along the way, relationships that illustrate things about their own personalities, while also creating a unique dynamic with others. Zoro and Sanji’s antagonism might be repetitive, but it’s also understandable — both the things that unite them (a strong sense of pride in their fighting capabilities) and the things that divide them (Zoro’s martial seriousness versus Sanji’s lady-obsessed distractibility) naturally provoke conflict between them. It’s not an arbitrary, author-assigned antagonism — it’s the natural result of two similar but distinct personalities clashing. When character conflict so clearly emerges from a character’s natural personality, it feels far more substantive and convincing.
Rivalries like Zoro and Sanji’s are pretty common in action anime, but One Piece’s crew possesses all sorts of other compelling dynamics. My own favorite relationship in the crew has to be the one between Usopp and Nami, two naturally suspicious people who’ve slowly, inevitably grown into best friends. Surrounded by superhumans in a terrifying world, Usopp and Nami frequently just have each other to relate to, each of them silently mouthing “are you seeing this” to each other as some new cataclysm befalls them. And as a result of their shared trials and common qualities, they’ve become a reliable pair even when the action stops. Usopp and Nami’s friendship feels both naturally reflective of their personalities and thoroughly earned by their shared experiences, while also serving as a refreshing male-female friendship with no romantic baggage.
With their lineup spanning from the childlike Chopper to veteran soldier Jimbei, the Straw Hats can frequently feel more like a multigenerational family than a group of largely equivalent warriors. And the crew truly act like it; while characters like Franky or Usopp work to impress their kid brother with inventions, the reserved Robin is happy to lounge on the upper deck, perhaps sharing an idle thought with the equally restrained Zoro. The group dynamics of the Straw Hats feel so clearly reflective of their fundamental personalities that when Jimbei joined the party, one of my first thoughts was, “Oh good, now Robin will have someone else to talk to.” And indeed, within just minutes of his formal acceptance, the two were already fast friends.
Even though One Piece contains some of the most ambitious, thrilling adventures in all of anime, the show’s secret weapon is that it doesn’t need to be thrilling to make for a delightful journey. Even its moments of peace are treasures, a truth exemplified by Oda’s regular title spreads of the crew just lounging and enjoying each other’s company. Of course, those wild adventures are made all the more satisfying by our understanding of this family’s mutual love, as they push beyond their boundaries to ensure they all make it home together. Though they’re easy to take for granted, One Piece is truly elevated by its distinct interpersonal relationships and the collective family they form. After all, what’s the point of going on an adventure without good friends to share it with?
Do you love writing? Do you love anime? If you have an idea for a features story, pitch it to Crunchyroll Features!