I was really hoping this was going to be good, because the animation is beautiful, clear, and tight: the eyes are drawn very interestingly, and the outfits are....creative, to say the least. And they had all this cool card-suit imagery that I was like, this is totally gonna tie in to things! But no, they had to give us flat characters and a thin plot, and no explanation for the cool imagery. :'( ...
I was really hoping this was going to be good, because the animation is beautiful, clear, and tight: the eyes are drawn very interestingly, and the outfits are....creative, to say the least. And they had all this cool card-suit imagery that I was like, this is totally gonna tie in to things! But no, they had to give us flat characters and a thin plot, and no explanation for the cool imagery. :'(
Spoilers abound, but the major ones are marked.
Plot was thin because, well, we don't find out the reason for everything until the last two episodes. It gets dumped on you, instead of teased out little by little, which would have been much more effective and artistic. All we know beforehand is that she ends up somehow
Spoiler Alert! Click to show or hide
jumping worlds and back through time
and dating a different guy each time. Characters were flat because there was no time to develop relationships. And the person she had the most episodes with turned out to be
Spoiler Alert! Click to show or hide
totally selfish and mentally disturbed.
And they didn't even flesh out his character!
What really horrified me was
Spoiler Alert! Click to show or hide
Toma's arc. Someone who drugs the person they proclaim to love, or locks them in a cage, is in serious need of mental help. If he really loved her he wouldn't try to take away her free will like that.
Oh, and the one guy who actually deserved attention? You know, Kent? The slightly nerdy looking one with the glasses who's actually normal? He only gets one episode. It's really not fair. He's the only one who doesn't force himself on her, or abuse her,
Spoiler Alert! Click to show or hide
(Toma's actions were definitely abuse)
or otherwise play around with her affections. Kent actually
cared about
her, and was willing to try to make changes in his life to be a good boyfriend.
I know this thing is based on an otome visual novel (basically, a dating sim where each guy has his own path, and depending on the choices you make you get a happy/sad ending), but since they were making into a show, they should've tied the plot together a little bit more. It seems like they tried...but it didn't work. Having little vignettes with each guy doesn't work when we don't know enough about the guys themselves and on top of that we're trying to solve a bigger mystery. And also, since as a story we expect some kind of closure, I think they should've chosen a guy for her to end up with. Maybe I'm only saying that because I want it, but not choosing a guy for her
and giving me a
deus-ex-machina ending in a show that has one dimensional characters really made me want something besides the art to enjoy!
And don't get me started on the heroine. I am in pretty much full agreement with the complaints of her having no personality. That works for a reader-insert visual novel, but not an anime. If I could give this a zero star rating, I would. Not even the art saves it.