This show has the potential to be a classic. But...
It took them three loosely connected episodes to get to the point of the series, and this is a Winter series, so it's likely to only be 12 or 13 episodes long. So as fascinating as the storyline might be so far, my worry is whether they'll have enough episodes to tell all (or even most) of the story threads they've started. This could easily ...
This show has the potential to be a classic. But...
It took them three loosely connected episodes to get to the point of the series, and this is a Winter series, so it's likely to only be 12 or 13 episodes long. So as fascinating as the storyline might be so far, my worry is whether they'll have enough episodes to tell all (or even most) of the story threads they've started. This could easily be a disappointing series ending in a tangled web of loose ends.
EDIT (March 19 2010): They pulled it off. This is by far the best series of the Winter 2010 season.
The storyline looks like it'll be full of surprises even if they don't manage to wrap them up properly. The opener starts off like it's for a motorcycle anime, but that's a complete red-herring. In just three episodes, it has evolved from a school-life story about a small-town boy who comes to the big city to change his life to a story of a strange super-powered fighter for justice to an urban fantasy where the conflicts of humans and spirit beings interact.
Through-out this seemingly chaotic jumble, the common thread is Ryugamine Mikado, the small-town boy who moves to the Ikebukuro section of Tokyo to live on his own and enroll in high school there. His point of view and those of his classmates are the glue that holds the series (so far) together. To be honest, the high schoolers are showing as fairly stereotypical characters: the shy, loser transfer student, the shy girl class-rep, the dumb-ass sidekick. But the characters aren't pure stereotypes. The one-line description doesn't do justice to the interactions the characters have with each other, which are as quirky as the storyline. Plus, there are are some exceptions to the rule, or does the girl who wanted to commit suicide but changed her mind count as a stereotype nowadays?
But the stereotypical high-schoolers are the viewers' oasis of familiarity in Ikebukuro. Humans aren't the only creatures who come to the big city to change their lives, and Ikebukuro seems to be a gathering place as well as an S-class battleground for spirit beings with their own agendas and rivalries. This is on top of the criminal gangs and other complexities of urban life facing teenagers as they grow up. The interweaving of the setting, the human and non-human characters is the high point of the series so far.
I love the animation style on this show too. It's a bit more impressionistic and stylized than the most realistically drawn anime, but the style isn't distracting. It also serves to accentuate the setting, with just enough skewed lines and other jarring elements to remind us that we are in a big, chaotic city full of life. The music also helps the series setting along more than usual too, with the same eclectic variety you can hear in a big city. After the rockin' opening theme, the incidental music can range from piano (first day of school) to accordion (a Russian encounter), to more typical synthesizer tones. This isn't just music to ignore, but it doesn't intrude, either.
All in all, this looks like the smartest new series in the Winter 2010 lineup. Whether it ends up as being the best will depend on where the story ends up.
(Edit 10 April 2010) - Well, it turns out this isn't a short-season anime, so I can't call it a "best ever" short season anime. But the good news is that means there are even more episodes to enjoy. Apart from that, this is still a classy, witty series. The multiple story lines interweave in complex patterns, the characters are multi-dimensional, and the stereotypes are not what they seem at first, and the sound and video craftsmanship are superb. The more I watch this series, the more I appreciate its combination of subtlety, action and mystery.
Read more