First I would like to apologise for any ensuing rants that occur within the review once I get going I tend to not be able to stop, also I didn't write this in order so it might end up a bit all over the place but I think I get the basic point accross. Also the rating is to do with comparison of animes OVERALL which is why it might seem low, I don't believe that a 5 for music happens unless ...
First I would like to apologise for any ensuing rants that occur within the review once I get going I tend to not be able to stop, also I didn't write this in order so it might end up a bit all over the place but I think I get the basic point accross. Also the rating is to do with comparison of animes OVERALL which is why it might seem low, I don't believe that a 5 for music happens unless your Skankfunk (Air Gear) for instance.
Well I'm personally a sucker for sports animes, though this is not technically speaking a 'sport' (though god knows anymore), but it follows the character styles and plot devices used in classic sports animes. So I was immediately looking forward to the series. One other reason was more specific, it was another anime about Mahjong, which in itself is a vastly fascinating game and I've always found that animes do a good job using it as a subject.
Why its good
I do consider 'Mahjong Animes' (thats right I'm making a new genre right here, right now) to be fairly special so I feel the best to look at Saki is to compare it with the others. Now the first thing about this is that it is FAR more commercial then the others which has its ups and its downs, the downs I'll talk about later, but the ups that come from it is the spreading of Mahjong as a game itself and the fact that hopefully it will compel people to look back at the others, which are well worth the watch. Also it will hopefully lead to more spins on the Mahjong Anime, this is just speculation the show itself shows this as the other Major Mahjong Animes were very serious and this shows that Mahjong can just be a game. Akagi definitely won't appeal to a lot of people because of its dark nature but its hard to say the same of Saki. All around it is very well crafted, the storyline is not complex like Shion no Ou the characters aren't as strong as in Akagi but I watch it every week and am never disappointed. It keeps things simple and does very well by it
Criticisms
I think my most crucial criticism of the series (so far obviously), is the fact that it dumbs down mahjong quite a lot I think, unlike Akagi and Shion no Ou it was made with us westerners (apparently that is an actual word, I'm skeptical myself) in mind. The depth that Akagi and Shion no Ou went into Mahjong made me stop and have to look back at things which I simply didn't understand, this was made to be easy to watch. This is probably more evident in the fact that the characters are basically there to look cute, I don't find that in itself a problem, but I don't like the idea that animes might loose some of their culture or worse still dumb it down simply because they believe either we won't understand or we are too lazy to find out. I find some of the characters depths to be far to shallow it seems like some characters have no background whatsoever (and they aren't exactly side characters) obviously theres room for expanding but it seems even the characters with backgrounds are given no mystery (except the captain) all the back stories are just handed over to us. This is obviously a little to much over analysis but what almost always draws me to an anime is the rich characters that star in them and how easily I become attached to them.
Summary
Though there are these criticisms, and it appears in size that there are more bad things then good things to say I hasten to add that I love this anime to bits and even got off my ass to get membership purely to watch this as soon as possible. Take the criticisms with a pinch of salt or, as most of you who read this probably will, disregard my comments all together and just sit back and enjoy yourselves =D because its hard to stretch out THIS ANIME IS AMAZING as much as very specific problems.
Read more